2003 Question 3
LL'LL: There is very little to criticize in this student's essay analysing tragic heroes in The Great Gatsby. There was virtually no plot summary; the only summary apparent was necessary to elaborate on the point being made. The author made his or her points extremely clear to the reader, and overall the analysis was accurate, well-organised and even enjoyable to read, which is hard to say for most AP essays. This student delved into all aspects of the character of Jay Gatsby, and makes the case for him being tragic in a pitiful, almost inevitable way, while also making the connection that Gatsby represents the whole of the Jazz Age and its failures and faults. I would wholeheartedly award this essay a nine, for it represents all the necessary traits a good AP essay should have. I will most definitely use this as a template for my own essays once I begin writing more of them.
C: This student did not do as good a job as the former student did with this prompt, though this essay is not without its merits. The author seemed unable to really articulate what he or she wanted to say about King Lear, and it was confusing while reading the essay where the plot summaries included wanted to go. In the end, the student does a nice job summing up her points about duty and how the lack of duty and the presence of greed and Lear's ego all lent to his place as a tragic figure, though these points were far less clear in the body text. Overall, I would give this student a six, for the knowledge is present, though its exercise was not as precise and direct as it could have been.
FF,: I find that this essay on One Flew Over The Cuckoo's Nest somewhat misses the intent of the prompt. Rather than examining the tragedy of one character, which would be the newest patient McMurphy, the author instead anaylses how the tragedy of McMurphy causes suffering for others. He or she merely writes off the tragedy of McMurphy as "the utmost tragedy", but fails to explain in any great depth why that is. Instead, the author goes on a lengthy plot summary of one of the final scenes, where a character commits suicide and McMurphy is sent off to electroshock therapy. In essence, this plot summary makes no final point in relation to the intent of the prompt, instead talking about the tragedy of other characters. I would give this essayist a lower score than a four, but I feel I must keep it at that level, for the author is fairly competent, I just believe that the plot summary takes up too much space and the final points about tragic heroes are never reached.
Sunday, December 15, 2013
Sunday, December 8, 2013
Close Reading The Fourth
http://www.theonion.com/articles/deformed-freak-born-without-penis,34732/
"Deformed Freak Born Without Penis"
I have to say, the Onion is a supreme satirical source. Their goal is always to poke holes in whatever they see fit to; in this instance it would be the reasons for the mistreatment of women. The authors of "Deformed Freak Born Without Penis" from December 3d achieve the incredibly satirical tone through the usage of diction, syntax, and details.
The authors of this article use very exaggerated, editorialized diction throughout the article to aid to the absurd, satirical tone. The first instance is in the title, where the woman in question (an unnamed subject) is described as a "deformed freak" for being born an anatomical woman. Already we are greeted with the tacit assertion that this "news" article functions not as an impartial report on information but as something very silly. In the second paragraph the woman's lack of a penis is called a "malady" and she is again described as "monstrous" and "bizarre." More diction such as "horrible", "incredibly crippling" and "malformed specimen" are used to describe the woman; the over-use of this kind of diction lowers the subject below human levels and lends to an absurd tone, which is what the authors were going for.
All of the syntax in articles from The Onion is very similar; as it is a satire of journalism, it is written in a very journalistic style. Each paragraph is generally short, using longer sentence lengths than are used in normal speech. Sentence length and style is not as varied as a piece of fiction or other writing, which is very representative of a journalistic style. The fact that this is obviously not real journalism adds yet another layer of absurdity to the article, as readers are beguiled (hopefully not completely) into believing that this article is an actual news story. There are also a large number of quotes from "sources", which further adds to the fake-news-article reality of the piece.
The details in this piece alone create the silliest atmosphere possible for a reader and lend greatly to the piece's absurdist tone. Most of the details come from "eyewitness" or "source" quotes, such as one from an obstetrictian who delivered the girl in question. He states that when the ultrasound showed that the fetus was a girl, he knew that "something was terribly, terribly wrong." He goes on to say that the pregnancy could not be terminated as planned, and that there "wasn't much hope to be had" for the girl to be born. Another man quoted is an onlooker, who gawks at the "freakish human anomaly" and declares that it's "hard not to stare" at her. These two people, who are obviously nonexistent, treat the girl as a non-human in the same vein as the rest of the article. Later, the girl's father expresses sadness and disappointment over his daughter's anatomy, stating that he was thankful "that my other two kids were born like that." As a general rule, The Onion's quoted folks say absurd, off-color or offensive things like they do here, and it adds to the journalistic style and satirical tone. It's incredibly hard to take these details seriously, which is exactly what the authors intended.
I hope no one that reads this post thinks that I am in some way anti-feminist and believe the crazy views supposedly outlined in this piece. The article works against what it means on the surface, criticizing the supposed "women-are-inferior-because-they-are-women" view still apparent in culture today. Obviously, the authors take it beyond the scope of reality, because women have advanced greatly in the past hundred years or so, and it would be absurd to think that a majority of people believed anything close to the statements in this article. But that is exactly what the Onion does best, and it is presented here in its fullest form.
"Deformed Freak Born Without Penis"
I have to say, the Onion is a supreme satirical source. Their goal is always to poke holes in whatever they see fit to; in this instance it would be the reasons for the mistreatment of women. The authors of "Deformed Freak Born Without Penis" from December 3d achieve the incredibly satirical tone through the usage of diction, syntax, and details.
The authors of this article use very exaggerated, editorialized diction throughout the article to aid to the absurd, satirical tone. The first instance is in the title, where the woman in question (an unnamed subject) is described as a "deformed freak" for being born an anatomical woman. Already we are greeted with the tacit assertion that this "news" article functions not as an impartial report on information but as something very silly. In the second paragraph the woman's lack of a penis is called a "malady" and she is again described as "monstrous" and "bizarre." More diction such as "horrible", "incredibly crippling" and "malformed specimen" are used to describe the woman; the over-use of this kind of diction lowers the subject below human levels and lends to an absurd tone, which is what the authors were going for.
All of the syntax in articles from The Onion is very similar; as it is a satire of journalism, it is written in a very journalistic style. Each paragraph is generally short, using longer sentence lengths than are used in normal speech. Sentence length and style is not as varied as a piece of fiction or other writing, which is very representative of a journalistic style. The fact that this is obviously not real journalism adds yet another layer of absurdity to the article, as readers are beguiled (hopefully not completely) into believing that this article is an actual news story. There are also a large number of quotes from "sources", which further adds to the fake-news-article reality of the piece.
The details in this piece alone create the silliest atmosphere possible for a reader and lend greatly to the piece's absurdist tone. Most of the details come from "eyewitness" or "source" quotes, such as one from an obstetrictian who delivered the girl in question. He states that when the ultrasound showed that the fetus was a girl, he knew that "something was terribly, terribly wrong." He goes on to say that the pregnancy could not be terminated as planned, and that there "wasn't much hope to be had" for the girl to be born. Another man quoted is an onlooker, who gawks at the "freakish human anomaly" and declares that it's "hard not to stare" at her. These two people, who are obviously nonexistent, treat the girl as a non-human in the same vein as the rest of the article. Later, the girl's father expresses sadness and disappointment over his daughter's anatomy, stating that he was thankful "that my other two kids were born like that." As a general rule, The Onion's quoted folks say absurd, off-color or offensive things like they do here, and it adds to the journalistic style and satirical tone. It's incredibly hard to take these details seriously, which is exactly what the authors intended.
I hope no one that reads this post thinks that I am in some way anti-feminist and believe the crazy views supposedly outlined in this piece. The article works against what it means on the surface, criticizing the supposed "women-are-inferior-because-they-are-women" view still apparent in culture today. Obviously, the authors take it beyond the scope of reality, because women have advanced greatly in the past hundred years or so, and it would be absurd to think that a majority of people believed anything close to the statements in this article. But that is exactly what the Onion does best, and it is presented here in its fullest form.
Sunday, November 24, 2013
Response to Course Material #3
Hamlet. Hamlet. Hamlet. Did I mention Hamlet? Yes, my friends, in case you haven't noticed, we've been reading Hamlet these past few weeks, and I must confess that my head begins to hurt after time with Shakespeare. I consider myself fairly competent with words and the English language, but trying to absorb Hamlet at the pace we took it was quite difficult. Many long passages and soliloquies went right over my head, though I'm sure that as I begin reading the text again I'll begin to see the meanings of these passages, along with the symbolic meanings as well. The passages that were especially confusing were Hamlet's soliloquies and the veiled-but-out-in-the-open declarations of Ophelia near the end, where I jokingly said that she was pregnant, and it turned out to be true. As a whole, I've enjoyed our initial reading of the text, and I look forward to delving into its depths in the days to come, especially the passages where Hamlet is consumed by angst. As a teenager, I'm practically wallowing in my own angst for the majority of the hours spent awake, and on only the most minute scale could I relate to Hamlet's own angst. Thankfully, I have good reason not to feel as close a bond with Hamlet's feelings: my father's alive, my mother is not incestuous, I'm not living in a cold stone castle up in Denmark all the year long having to deal with courtly silliness, etc. On some level Hamlet's thoughts on religion are like mine, as I often ponder religion and how it affects people and society, though I am not torn like he is between his duty to God and to his father. Shakespeare obviously lived in a highly religious time, so I don't expect any major rebuttals to established religious theory appearing in the text, though I am interested to see what he thinks about the religion of the time.
Otherwise, our energy in AP Lit has not been devoted to much else, except the finishing of Death of a Salesman and the sporadic analysis of mood and atmosphere. I have to say, those exercises are rather interesting. I've never undergone such a thorough discussion on how an author creates feelings and moods and the such with words before, and its fascinating. When we took that still from Twelve Angry Men and wrote a little blurb describing that picture it was amazing how much detail can be extracted and simplified to relate back to a single word, in this case "tense." These discussions are also exercises in control: one has to be in complete control of a passage in terms of the language he or she uses in order to put across that mood. Language is an infinitely malleable construct, which is both wonderful and harrowing, as it can easily get out of hand. I can recall many times where I've attempted to write and a stream of words has poured out of me, but when I look back on it I say to myself "this is total crap." With these discussions I'm starting to see different options in my writing: I don't necessarily have to spit out a stream of big words and long sentences to look good anymore, I can write something simpler that puts across a lot more. A lot of that relates back to what Ms. Holmes lauds as the "adjective crack-pipe", a dangerous tool that I often draw deeply from. I'm starting to realize that I don't need so many damn modifiers in my writing, and am very conscious now of when they're effective and when they're merely clutter.
Otherwise, our energy in AP Lit has not been devoted to much else, except the finishing of Death of a Salesman and the sporadic analysis of mood and atmosphere. I have to say, those exercises are rather interesting. I've never undergone such a thorough discussion on how an author creates feelings and moods and the such with words before, and its fascinating. When we took that still from Twelve Angry Men and wrote a little blurb describing that picture it was amazing how much detail can be extracted and simplified to relate back to a single word, in this case "tense." These discussions are also exercises in control: one has to be in complete control of a passage in terms of the language he or she uses in order to put across that mood. Language is an infinitely malleable construct, which is both wonderful and harrowing, as it can easily get out of hand. I can recall many times where I've attempted to write and a stream of words has poured out of me, but when I look back on it I say to myself "this is total crap." With these discussions I'm starting to see different options in my writing: I don't necessarily have to spit out a stream of big words and long sentences to look good anymore, I can write something simpler that puts across a lot more. A lot of that relates back to what Ms. Holmes lauds as the "adjective crack-pipe", a dangerous tool that I often draw deeply from. I'm starting to realize that I don't need so many damn modifiers in my writing, and am very conscious now of when they're effective and when they're merely clutter.
Sunday, November 17, 2013
Yet Again, Open Prompts
2009 Question 3
Student 3A: This student's response to Henrik Ibsen's The Wild Duck does a more-than-adequate job of answering the prompt on symbols. While at times the author does tend to summarize the plot, he or she almost always relates it back to the prompt. The symbol of analysis here is the titular duck, which represents many facets of the characters. The student clearly shows us what the symbol relates to ("[the duck] comes to symbolize the family's tranquility and happiness", "the symbol of the wild duck is used to represent the family's innocence and happiness", etc.) and when, using the context of the plot to do so. However, I do not think so highly of this author's thesis, which was rather vague: ". . . Ibsen uses an overarching symbol of a wild duck in order to highlight the events and development of characters throughout." This thesis made it difficult to navigate through the body, as each section did not clearly relate to a part of the thesis. Overall, I would give this student an 8, for the essay was good, but the thesis and structure needed tending to.
Student 3B: This student's response to Tennessee Williams' A Streetcar Named Desire lacked an extremely clear focus as to what the main symbol, a lampshade, accomplished in the play. While it was clear, it was not clear enough to award this student anything higher than a 6. This student actually speaks more of revealing the truth, rather than the hiding of it, as the latter is what the lampshade seems to accomplish in this play. The majority of the third paragraph, for example, outlines Blanche's exposure of truth, the truth being that her first husband was gay. Only in the last sentence ("she began a pattern of hiding what's real") does the author address the actual meaning of the symbol, and he or she does not clearly relate it back to lampshades. Plot summary is also used extensively, though it has more of a purpose in the third paragraph than the second; it is merely superfluous in the latter. This student's flaws in his or her essay are not enough to cause it to plummet into the depths of threes and twos, though they are quite apparent.
Student 3C: This student's response to Things Fall Apart was focused on a symbol present, a machete, though it lacked any complexity of argument and evidence. The author claims that the machete represents "power and strength", which is clearly stated in the thesis, though much of the evidence presented is unrelated to the thesis, such as "[the white men] were converting his family and friends to Christianity" and his assertion that women do not carry machetes. It is very hard to make sense of this essay, as the author offers no concrete evidence. The sentence structure is also very simplistic, with almost every single one being extremely blunt and declarative. The conclusion also does very little concluding: the author asserts that the main character would not "be who he was" without the machete, but does not relate that point back to any evidence in his body or the text, and looking at the body there is very little there to support that point. The only reason I would give this essay a four would be that it is not incomprehensible, and that there is at least an attempt to relate evidence back to the thesis.
Student 3A: This student's response to Henrik Ibsen's The Wild Duck does a more-than-adequate job of answering the prompt on symbols. While at times the author does tend to summarize the plot, he or she almost always relates it back to the prompt. The symbol of analysis here is the titular duck, which represents many facets of the characters. The student clearly shows us what the symbol relates to ("[the duck] comes to symbolize the family's tranquility and happiness", "the symbol of the wild duck is used to represent the family's innocence and happiness", etc.) and when, using the context of the plot to do so. However, I do not think so highly of this author's thesis, which was rather vague: ". . . Ibsen uses an overarching symbol of a wild duck in order to highlight the events and development of characters throughout." This thesis made it difficult to navigate through the body, as each section did not clearly relate to a part of the thesis. Overall, I would give this student an 8, for the essay was good, but the thesis and structure needed tending to.
Student 3B: This student's response to Tennessee Williams' A Streetcar Named Desire lacked an extremely clear focus as to what the main symbol, a lampshade, accomplished in the play. While it was clear, it was not clear enough to award this student anything higher than a 6. This student actually speaks more of revealing the truth, rather than the hiding of it, as the latter is what the lampshade seems to accomplish in this play. The majority of the third paragraph, for example, outlines Blanche's exposure of truth, the truth being that her first husband was gay. Only in the last sentence ("she began a pattern of hiding what's real") does the author address the actual meaning of the symbol, and he or she does not clearly relate it back to lampshades. Plot summary is also used extensively, though it has more of a purpose in the third paragraph than the second; it is merely superfluous in the latter. This student's flaws in his or her essay are not enough to cause it to plummet into the depths of threes and twos, though they are quite apparent.
Student 3C: This student's response to Things Fall Apart was focused on a symbol present, a machete, though it lacked any complexity of argument and evidence. The author claims that the machete represents "power and strength", which is clearly stated in the thesis, though much of the evidence presented is unrelated to the thesis, such as "[the white men] were converting his family and friends to Christianity" and his assertion that women do not carry machetes. It is very hard to make sense of this essay, as the author offers no concrete evidence. The sentence structure is also very simplistic, with almost every single one being extremely blunt and declarative. The conclusion also does very little concluding: the author asserts that the main character would not "be who he was" without the machete, but does not relate that point back to any evidence in his body or the text, and looking at the body there is very little there to support that point. The only reason I would give this essay a four would be that it is not incomprehensible, and that there is at least an attempt to relate evidence back to the thesis.
Wednesday, November 13, 2013
Summary and Analysis of "Death of a Salesman"
Summary
Death of a Salesman begins with Willy Loman
returning from a long sales trip, exhausted. His wife, Linda, greets him as he
arrives, and pressures him to talk to his boss and get a job in the city.
Upstairs, their two sons, Biff and Happy, lie awake reminiscing about the days
of youth. They discuss their father’s hallucinations, which occur more
frequently whenever Biff comes back to town. The reader experiences one of
these flashbacks first-hand while Willy wanders around the outside of his
house. Happy, concerned, goes downstairs to try and coax his father to go to bed.
Eventually, Willy’s visions grow too intense and he begins shouting. Biff comes
downstairs asking about his father, and Linda confronts him about his decisions
and the disrespect directed towards Willy. To calm his father down, Happy presents an idea to Biff to sell sporting goods, and Willy suggests he take it to Bill Oliver, one of Biff's old employers who Willy is sure will remember him. The next
day, Biff leaves the house early to meet with Oliver while Willy goes to New
York to talk to Howard Wagner, the boss of his firm, about a city job. A dinner
between the father and his sons is arranged after. Willy arrives in Howard’s
office, but after Howard rejects his proposal, saying that there is no room for
him. Willy is distraught and begins to shout at Howard about “promises” made to
him earlier in his career. Willy is promptly fired; and he wanders out of
the building talking to himself, going to Charley’s workplace to ask him for
money. When he’s there, he meets Bernard, Charley’s son and a childhood friend
of Biff’s, who is now a successful lawyer. Willy asks Bernard what the answer
to success is and why Biff never achieved it, but Bernard cannot provide a
concrete answer. Meanwhile, Happy and Biff arrive at the dinner, and Biff tells
Happy of his failure with Bill Oliver. Biff had waited for hours in Oliver’s
office, until he finally stepped out, where Oliver did not recognize him and
barely paid him any mind. Biff plans to tell Willy all of this, but when he
does Willy denies him. Happy eventually leaves with two women and drags Biff
with him, leaving Willy in a hallucinatory state. Here, Willy recalls how Biff
discovered that he had an affair with a secretary in Boston, which is the main
reason for Biff’s distancing from his father and his wanderings through life.
Happy
and Biff return home after leaving their father at the restaurant to find Linda
angry at both of them. Biff, enraged by the constant lies of Happy and his
father, declares that he must tell Willy the truth about himself, despite
Linda’s protestations. Willy continues to ignore Biff's assertions that he is no good, and eventually Biff collapses on him, crying and hugging him. Willy takes this as a sign that Biff has forgiven him, and in a state of elation crashes his car and kills himself to grant Biff twenty thousand dollars in insurance claims that Willy assumes Biff will use to go into business. The play ends with Willy's funeral, and at it Happy declares he willy follow in his father's footsteps; Biff firmly decides to forge his own path.
Analysis
Arthur
Miller’s Death of a Salesman suggests
that society’s superficial idea of success does not always match that of the
individual, and that the denial of one’s true dreams can lead to catastrophic
consequences.
The setting of Death of a Salesman shifts between the Lomans’ home and the city of
New York. At the house, the walls are broken up by spaces to allow characters
to pass between them in Willy’s flashbacks; they cannot do this during the
present. The ability for characters to pass through walls in Willy’s flashbacks
demonstrate his unreliability as a narrator, for no person can simply walk
through walls in reality; as well as being a practical measure. In New York,
Willy travels to the office of Howard Wagner, the head of the firm he works
for, and later to Frank’s Chop House, a restaurant.
Characters of Greatest Import:
Willy Loman: The main protagonist of this
play, Loman is a hard-working salesman whose dream is to achieve “success.” His
father abandoned him and his brother when they were young, going of too Alaska,
which instilled in Willy the desire to make it on his own out in the frontier,
though his mind was eventually changed when he heard tales of a successful,
“well-liked” salesman who was known throughout the land and lived comfortably.
Sucked in by this idea he worked and worked but never achieved this vision.
Willy is extremely prideful and desires control, though he is also wracked by
guilt, not only towards his wife and children, but also towards himself. Willy
experiences many flashbacks to happier times, which frighten the rest of his
family. His memories are often distorted and cannot be taken as fact.
Linda Loman: Willy’s husband, Linda
struggles with Willy and his passionate feelings daily. She loves him despite
Willy’s sometimes cruel treatment of her, even though Willy is unfaithful to
her. Linda does not know how to keep Willy from harming her and himself because
of her love and her belief that he is his own man, and can be seen as an
enabler. Linda’s relationship with her sons has been strained due to their
inattention to Willy, especially with Biff.
Biff Loman: Biff was the former captain of
his high school football team and had dreams of playing professionally, even
playing at Ebbets Field. Willy showered Biff with praise in his youth, building
up his confidence and abilities and largely ignoring his other son. Biff later
lost faith in his father’s praise when he discovered the affair Willy was
having with a secretary. He then wandered through life, forgetting his dreams
and going out west to work as a rancher, though he too feels guilt, especially
for not telling Linda about the affair. Biff is a kleptomaniac who steals
whenever things seem to be going right, as a form of self-sabotage. He rejects
the dreams of being a salesman that Willy planted in him and wants something
more down-to-earth.
Harold “Happy” Loman. Happy is the neglected child of
the Loman family. Due to Willy constantly lauding Biff, Happy was starved for
attention and had to work for his father’s validation. Happy is moderately
“successful”: he has an apartment, a car, and women. Both he and
Happy often treat women as objects and pay them little regard as human beings,
as demonstrated in the restaurant scene and their remembrances of youth. Unlike
Biff, Happy believes in the dreams their father told them about, and at the end
of the play declares that he will follow in his father’s footsteps and go into
business. His name is ironic as he is not really fulfilled or happy in life.
Ben Loman: Willy’s deceased brother, Ben
is Willy’s model for success. At the age of eighteen Ben travelled to Africa
and eventually made a fortune in diamond mining. His relationship with his
brother was never good, visiting him sparingly and never staying long; and none
of Ben’s wealth ever came into Willy’s hands. It is unsure if Ben ever actually
visited the Lomans, as whenever Willy talks to Ben in a flashback the other
characters’ speech reverts to a highly simplified form, as if Willy were making
it up.
Charley and Bernard: Charley is Willy’s closest
friend, and Bernard is his son. Charley is a moderately successful man it would
seem; he’s able to lend money to Willy on a regular basis and heads his own
business. Bernard is a successful lawyer who was a childhood friend of Biff’s.
Willy once did not believe Bernard would be successful because he was not “well
liked”, but in his old age now looks up to him for the “answer” to success.
Major Motifs:
Machines
and Nature: I have thought that the juxtaposition of these opposites, which occurs
mainly in Willy and Biff, represents the conflicts between what the individual
wants and what a society has imposed on him. It also serves as a criticism of
society, represented in machines, which are usually broken and in need of
fixing (the washing machine, refrigerator, Willy’s car, etc.). Both Willy and
Biff desire to “use their muscles”, as it were, and work with “natural” things,
such as Willy building the roof and porch and Biff working as a rancher. Willy
and Biff have had their true dreams repressed over the years, though, not only
by themselves but by outside forces (society to Willy, Willy to Biff). The one
machine that does not seem to malfunction is Howard’s wire recorder, which is
so frightening to Willy because it cannot lie like he can; it perfectly
replicates the past, which is something Willy constantly strives to deny.
Stealing:
There are several instances of stealing in this play, the most notable being
the theft of Bill Oliver’s fountain pen by Biff near the end. Biff’s stealing
was initially encouraged by Willy, as exemplified by the football and the
construction equipment stolen in one of Willy’s flashbacks. Later in life Biff
steals to sabotage himself because he cannot live with the pressure his father
put on him as a child, constantly praising him in order to drive his success.
Biff’s stealing in his youth seemed to have more of a purpose other than
self-sabotage, whether it be to practice football or to help his father with
building a porch. I would assume that Biff neither desires nor needs a golden
fountain pen, or the suits he stole in Kansas City. These thefts point to
another motif, superficiality, which will be discussed later.
Values
of Success and the American Dream: Willy is constantly bombarding his family
with his idea of what success should be, saying that if a man is “well-liked”
he can and will get anywhere he needs to in life. He speaks nothing of actual
hard work, despite knowing hard work all too well, though the work Willy really
revels in and works hard at is not the kind of work presented in these values.
Willy’s successful idol is his brother Ben, who made his fortune mining
diamonds in Africa. The circumstances through which Ben came to gain this
fortune are hazy; and Ben never offers Willy an answer when Willy implores him
for “the secret” to success. When we step back and remove ourselves from Willy’s
confused perception of himself, we see that he is nothing more than a
lower-class, hard-working salesman who never made it anywhere, despite having
an impossible dream to do so. Willy’s dreams to become the salesman who is
well-liked and known all over the country are impossible because they are not
actually his; American society has implanted these values in him through Dave
Singleman, an old, successful salesman whose realization of wealth and comfort
replaced much of Willy’s true desires.
Superficiality:
Willy’s notion of how to achieve success is a purely superficial one: if one is
“well-liked”, and only this, he will make it. He does not take into account a
person’s inner character or any beliefs or dreams that a person may have. Both
the suit and the fountain pen that Biff steals are superficial status symbols
that point to nothing inward. The Loman’s refrigerator was bought on the basis
of advertisement size, assuming that if the ad was bigger, the refrigerator would
be better (this is not the case). Biff and Happy’s treatment of women also
demonstrates supreme superficiality, as Happy treats women as prizes to be had,
not people, and does not care about them as people. All of these
superficialities in the play point to Miller’s distaste for American superficiality,
which was running rampant in 1949, the year he wrote this play.
Selling
of ideas and the self: The question that is often brought up about Willy is “what
does he sell”; and Miller provides no concrete answer. One answer is that Willy
sells the idea of selling itself, not to customers, but to everyone around him.
Biff is told by Willy that he will go into business and be a salesman just like
his father (on the basis of being well-liked). Linda is reassured by her
husband that he is a successful salesman and that selling is a good job, and
Linda believes him, backing him up when Ben questions Willy’s decision to sell.
Dave Singleman, Willy’s inspiration, sold Willy the idea of selling a long time
ago. And in turn, society sells us the idea of selling along with old Dave.
Death: The
main death in this play is obviously the death of Willy, which is foreshadowed
from the opening scene (from the title, too) until he crashes his car at the
end. Not only does Willy die, but many others, such as Ben, Willy’s father, his
old boss who promised him a promotion, and many of Willy’s old clients have
died. The death of his boss and clients show that selling itself is dying, as
well as Howard not being able to fit Willy into an office job, as there are
only six salesmen on the floor. Along with physical death, Willy dies “the
death of a salesman” in the office scene where Howard treats him like a child
and fires him, destroying once and for all the dream that Willy worked so hard
for but never achieved. In the end, Willy kills himself to try and jumpstart
Biff along a “successful” path, as the insurance money earned from the crashing
of the car would be more than enough to get him along. Willy, however, never
realizes who Biff really is, despite Biff up and saying it to his face just
before he kills himself.
Contradictions
and Lies: Every single member of the Loman family is guilty of contradicting
and/or lying to themselves or others. Willy believes he is successful one
minute and then declares himself a failure the next; he refuses to believe that
Biff cannot be a salesman; he can seem so sure of his position and then tell
himself that he isn’t settled yet; the list continues. Happy emulates his father
in that he compulsively lies, often with a straight face, especially in the
restaurant scene where much of the dialogue is built off of Happy’s lies
surrounding Biff’s meeting with Bill Oliver. Linda knows that Willy is not who
he builds himself up to be yet she can’t bring herself to tell him that,
effectively lying to him by supporting this vision. Both Willy and Biff lie to
themselves about their true dreams and desires, pursuing things that they do
not really want. These contradictions and lies bring forth the conflict and
contradictions between what an individual wants and what a society wants for an
individual, which is the cornerstone of Miller’s ideas in this play.
Conflict:
The Loman family seems to be in constant conflict with each other, whether it
be verbal or physical. The most obvious conflict is between Biff and Willy, who
are at odds with each other over Biff’s life decisions. At the same time, these
two characters experience deep internal conflicts over their dreams. Happy competes
with Biff for their father’s attention, whether it is negative attention or
not. Linda is conflicted internally over whether or not to dispose of the
rubber tube that Willy plans to gas himself with, and she does not know how to
confront Willy about the tough issues in his life and still let him remain
himself. Willy has a major conflict with Howard Wagner over his job, which
parallels the conflict between Linda and Willy. Their conflict stems from Willy’s
weariness and his desire for control: he dominates any conversation they have
with each other and often tells Linda to be quiet when she tries to interject. Though
the tone shifts from character to character in this play, the tone of the Loman
family is very similar, and could be described as tense and argumentative. The
Lomans are constantly talking down to each other and have a difficult time
communicating effectively.
Many of these motifs, notably stealing, conflict, contradictions, and death, are direct consequences of the individual's denial of his or her true dreams. Willy's mind, body, and family have all depreciated because of the dreams implanted in him. These are the "catastrophic consequences" spoken of in the theme statement: the loss of one's body, mind, and family.
Quotes:
"But then, it's what I always wanted. My own apartment, a car, and plenty of women. And still, goddammit, I'm lonely!" Happy, p. 23
This quote exemplifies the ideas that Miller criticizes in Death of a Salesman and demonstrates how they do not fulfill any real needs. Happy may have his superficial success of property (this includes women; he treats them terribly) and money, but he really is not happy.
This quote emphasizes one of Miller's main points in the book, that not all people are "leaders of men" and that not everyone can and should go out and attempt to be one. It also brings Willy's conflicts and problems down to the broadest level possible, which is another piece that the play tries to accomplish.
Sunday, November 10, 2013
Close Reading the Third
"The Ultimate Guide to Writing Better Than You Normally Do" by Colin Nissan
http://www.mcsweeneys.net/articles/the-ultimate-guide-to-writing-better-than-you-normally-do
Finally, some advice about writing I can use! Colin Nissan in this 2012 article from McSweeny's satirizes writers' insatiable desire to become better by offering up some helpful tips; and as we are all writers in this class, I think we can relate to some of the themes and realities he touches on. Nissan effectively communicates his work through syntax, diction and details.
This piece is arranged as if it were some sort of self-help pamphlet, and with each section, the syntax changes to fit the particularities of that part. Take the first section, offering the advice to "write every day", where the syntax is intentionally blunt and disjointed. Only one sentence in this section is of considerable length, while the others are on the shorter side, especially the first, which offers only the blunt statement of "Writing is a muscle." Nissan uses asyndeton in the third sentence to speed its pace along and help it stick in one's head; while the final sentence is technically not a sentence. It's as if we are listening to a personal trainer breaking up a workout routine for us with these quick statements, trying to implant an idea in our heads. Though the third section contains even blunter phrases ("The blank white page"; "El Pollo Loco"), it's syntax is markedly different from the first's in that it includes six questions grouped in threes. This demonstrates the "rule of three", a technique often used to drive home a point or to draw attention to a specific section. Here, it draws the reader in by creating an initial tone of support, as if we were reading a gun-ho self-help sermon: "was Picasso intimidated by the blank canvas? Was Mozart intimidated by the blank sheet music? Was Edison intimidated by the blank lightbulb?" Though when Nissan asks the next three questions, the tone is no longer supportive but exposes the reality of this writer's situation, still grouped in the happy three: "Why did I quit my job at TJ Maxx to write full-time? Can/should I eat this entire box of Apple Jacks? Is The Price is Right on at 10 or 11?" Through this syntax, Nissan pokes fun at the obviously struggling writer attempting to get something done.
The diction, like the syntax, varies from section to section, and while it is mostly colloquial there are parts where elevated diction appears. In the second section, about the dangers of procrastination, diction like "alluring siren", "wicked temptress", and "seafaring wench" takes the terms of procrastination to the extreme, a tactic often used in satiric writing. The warning against procrastination is comically intensified by using this diction. Nissan takes on a fear-instilling tone by using the phrases "El Diablo Blanco" (The White Devil) and "El Pollo Loco" (The Crazy Chicken) in the third paragraph, as non-English phrases are sometimes used to generate feelings of fear and unfamiliarity in writing. Though what he is describing is merely a blank piece of paper, taking things to the extreme by using non-English diction again intensifies the affect it has on the reader. Also, the use of non-English words or phrases in satire often points at the pseudo-intellectuality of the speaker, as here he is trying to be elevated. Colloquial diction is found all throughout the piece, but it sticks out occasionally. In the fourth section, the speaker criticizes Mark Twain's statement "Show, don't tell", by saying "Thanks for nothing, Mr. Cryptic." In every day speech, people often make names out of non-nouns to mock or speak sarcastically of someone, and this is exactly what Nissan does here. In the sixth section, Nissan uses the word "literally" and "goddamn" to create a strongly colloquial feel in describing the difficulty of Sudoko. No intellectual writer would use "goddamn" or "literal" offhandedly, and the usage here increases the colloquial tone of the piece.
The details of this piece work to shine a light on a writer's assumed destitute living situation, poking fun at the pre-fame phase of every writer's career where he devotes all his energy to writing. The speaker questions the writer's decision to quit his former job at TJ Maxx and become a writer in the third section. Other details such as eating a box of Apple Jacks and watching The Price is Right all contribute to the feeling that this writer is living a not-so-good life. Those who spend their days watching TV and eating out of boxes of cereal are not generally considered by society to be successful. Other details such as the googling of television characters to put off writing and the "little" house of the writer demonstrate his lack of money and difficulties with writing. It is also implied in the last section that the writer's "demons" are actually psychological disorders in need of treatment; perhaps this implied imbalance of the mind is also poking fun at writing itself, calling it a disorder that drives one to eat boxes of Apple Jacks and the like.
As a writer myself, I know how one can be drawn in by the temptations of procrastination and the fear of the blank page, but like Nissan says, all you have to do is exercise. His wonderful satire of the writer and his struggles is firmly communicated through his usage of varied syntax, colloquial and elevated diction, and details about a writer's life.
http://www.mcsweeneys.net/articles/the-ultimate-guide-to-writing-better-than-you-normally-do
Finally, some advice about writing I can use! Colin Nissan in this 2012 article from McSweeny's satirizes writers' insatiable desire to become better by offering up some helpful tips; and as we are all writers in this class, I think we can relate to some of the themes and realities he touches on. Nissan effectively communicates his work through syntax, diction and details.
This piece is arranged as if it were some sort of self-help pamphlet, and with each section, the syntax changes to fit the particularities of that part. Take the first section, offering the advice to "write every day", where the syntax is intentionally blunt and disjointed. Only one sentence in this section is of considerable length, while the others are on the shorter side, especially the first, which offers only the blunt statement of "Writing is a muscle." Nissan uses asyndeton in the third sentence to speed its pace along and help it stick in one's head; while the final sentence is technically not a sentence. It's as if we are listening to a personal trainer breaking up a workout routine for us with these quick statements, trying to implant an idea in our heads. Though the third section contains even blunter phrases ("The blank white page"; "El Pollo Loco"), it's syntax is markedly different from the first's in that it includes six questions grouped in threes. This demonstrates the "rule of three", a technique often used to drive home a point or to draw attention to a specific section. Here, it draws the reader in by creating an initial tone of support, as if we were reading a gun-ho self-help sermon: "was Picasso intimidated by the blank canvas? Was Mozart intimidated by the blank sheet music? Was Edison intimidated by the blank lightbulb?" Though when Nissan asks the next three questions, the tone is no longer supportive but exposes the reality of this writer's situation, still grouped in the happy three: "Why did I quit my job at TJ Maxx to write full-time? Can/should I eat this entire box of Apple Jacks? Is The Price is Right on at 10 or 11?" Through this syntax, Nissan pokes fun at the obviously struggling writer attempting to get something done.
The diction, like the syntax, varies from section to section, and while it is mostly colloquial there are parts where elevated diction appears. In the second section, about the dangers of procrastination, diction like "alluring siren", "wicked temptress", and "seafaring wench" takes the terms of procrastination to the extreme, a tactic often used in satiric writing. The warning against procrastination is comically intensified by using this diction. Nissan takes on a fear-instilling tone by using the phrases "El Diablo Blanco" (The White Devil) and "El Pollo Loco" (The Crazy Chicken) in the third paragraph, as non-English phrases are sometimes used to generate feelings of fear and unfamiliarity in writing. Though what he is describing is merely a blank piece of paper, taking things to the extreme by using non-English diction again intensifies the affect it has on the reader. Also, the use of non-English words or phrases in satire often points at the pseudo-intellectuality of the speaker, as here he is trying to be elevated. Colloquial diction is found all throughout the piece, but it sticks out occasionally. In the fourth section, the speaker criticizes Mark Twain's statement "Show, don't tell", by saying "Thanks for nothing, Mr. Cryptic." In every day speech, people often make names out of non-nouns to mock or speak sarcastically of someone, and this is exactly what Nissan does here. In the sixth section, Nissan uses the word "literally" and "goddamn" to create a strongly colloquial feel in describing the difficulty of Sudoko. No intellectual writer would use "goddamn" or "literal" offhandedly, and the usage here increases the colloquial tone of the piece.
The details of this piece work to shine a light on a writer's assumed destitute living situation, poking fun at the pre-fame phase of every writer's career where he devotes all his energy to writing. The speaker questions the writer's decision to quit his former job at TJ Maxx and become a writer in the third section. Other details such as eating a box of Apple Jacks and watching The Price is Right all contribute to the feeling that this writer is living a not-so-good life. Those who spend their days watching TV and eating out of boxes of cereal are not generally considered by society to be successful. Other details such as the googling of television characters to put off writing and the "little" house of the writer demonstrate his lack of money and difficulties with writing. It is also implied in the last section that the writer's "demons" are actually psychological disorders in need of treatment; perhaps this implied imbalance of the mind is also poking fun at writing itself, calling it a disorder that drives one to eat boxes of Apple Jacks and the like.
As a writer myself, I know how one can be drawn in by the temptations of procrastination and the fear of the blank page, but like Nissan says, all you have to do is exercise. His wonderful satire of the writer and his struggles is firmly communicated through his usage of varied syntax, colloquial and elevated diction, and details about a writer's life.
Sunday, October 27, 2013
Responses to Course Material #2
Woo hoo! We're off on yet another adventure in AP Lit down the "Scrutiny-of-American-Society-and-Culture" Road! I am speaking, of course, of Death of a Salesman, which, in between discussions of poetry and how to answer multiple choice questions, is the main focus of our energy this time around. I can see why Salesman and The American Dream are read in direct succession, as they deal with very similar topics; and I'm loving the discussions we're having. Like Albee, Miller delves into the American Dream and how it has corrupted those who choose to follow it so dearly; and as we see Willy Loman wander strangely through visions and reality throughout Death of a Salesman, we are reminded of the contradictory and confused characters Albee presented to us only a month ago. On Friday, we were presented with several points of view on whether Salesman is a true tragedy, as it is often called, and after some thinking I have to say that, in a Shakespearean sense, it does not function as one. There are no noble characters, very little talk of revenge, and no unrealistic bloodbath at the end (though Willy does kill himself), and I don't think Miller intended for this play to be a traditional tragedy, as he highlighted in his essay on tragedy. He writes that tragedy is not exclusively reserved for nobility, and that commoners like Willy can be tragic as well, and I think he accomplishes this goal. I'm sure there'll be a big hullabaloo about this during discussions tomorrow, and I'd like to see how this viewpoint is challenged.
Otherwise, we've been doing some lovely little discussions about poetry, really digging into the meanings that so few words convey. It seems like such a long time ago when we first read "My Father's Song" by Simon Ortiz; and it's amazing how much we pulled out of it. All of the images, the diction and language Ortiz uses, the circularity with the first and last lines, all of it seemed so mundane and normal the first time I read it. I'd read poetry before, but I'd never read into it, which is kind of disappointing to me, because I realize now how much I've missed in past readings of poetry. I could already feel my poetry skills sharpening when next we read "Promises Like Pie-Crust", which had just as many layers of meaning to it, revolving around metaphors of chains and old English proverbs. I'm really enjoying going deeper into poetry, because a good poet can accomplish so much with so little, and that is fascinating.
Our continued practice with AP Exam material is going swimmingly as well, I think. I was rather surprised at how well Simon Tessemer and I did answering the questions on the excerpt from Troilus and Cressida, considering how dense Shakespeare is. I doubt the questions on the actual AP test will be as easy as the ones presented in that old practice test, as the tests shift from year to year, and we could be slammed with some of the most difficult questions that have ever been written. This is of course why Ms. Holmes goes over techniques such as reading the passage, then the stems, then going back in for a closer look. As much as I'd rather be discussing books 'n' such in AP Lit, this is, after all, a class preparing us for the all-important exam in May, so I guess we'd better include some work on how that exam is written and how it functions. I'm more worried about the essays anyway, though we did get some good work done on how to write a closed prompt with "Promises Like Pie-Crust", which is very similar to an open prompt in that everything relates back to meaning, but closed prompts are far more localized as they're about provided excerpts. This is a great boon to anyone taking the exam, as he or she does not have to wrack his brain about some specific image or symbol that he or she can't remember; instead it's right in front of him.
Sunday, October 20, 2013
Open Prompts #2
2004 Question 3
Response "N": I was rather impressed with this student's response to the prompt, where he or she used Candide to answer the prompt, which deals with questions raised in literature and how authors answer them. Though the student did tend to summarize quite a bit in the first paragraph, all of the summarizing was relevant to his or her analysis. The student goes into great detail to explain how the central question in Candide, "Is this the best of all possible worlds", is answered and how it relates to the book's meaning. The author tells us of Candide's exploits throughout the book and how he is always unsatisfied with the worlds he encounters, which leads him to the conclusion that "we must tend our garden" when it comes to the world, meaning we all must do what is necessary to keep this world better. The student mainly examines details from the plot, such as Candide's expulsion from his castle, his time spent in war, and his journey to the mythic El Dorado, though she does not do this simply to summarize. With each point the author ties it back to the central question, saying, in the case of El Dorado, that Candide could not reconcile his already-embedded sense of greed and lust in a society where greed and lust did not exist. Though the student does not directly state it, he or she does tie the question and his or her points back to the meaning of the book in the third paragraph, using Candide's answer to the central question to back up the book's point that "we all must strive to make each individual life the best possible." Overall, I would give this student a solid 8, for though he or she did a wonderful job responding to the prompt, there was enough summarizing present to knock it back a point.
Response "J": Compared to the first response, this takes quite a dive in quality of evidence. This essay is about Huckleberry Finn and the question "what does it mean to be free", and the author sets us up for something great, with the opportunity for many specific details, though he or she does not deliver to the fullest extent. The first paragraph is essentially plot summary, with the author telling us how Jim and Huck are both enslaved in different ways and escape on a raft to escape that slavery, but he or she does not attempt to connect with the central question or meaning in any way. In the following paragraphs many attempts to relate details and images from the text to the question are made, but they are all to vague to be concrete. Take the author's point that "When in town or with the 'King' or 'Duke', Huck and Jim must hide their feelings for each other because of society's conventions about race", which addresses an important issue in the book, but doesn't relate the point made back to the question in full. One can discern a skeleton of what this essayist is saying, but it is in no way fleshed out enough to be given a high score. I think a 5 would be an appropriate score for this student.
Response "uu": The sparsity of this essay was an immediate tip-off to the fact that I wasn't going to be reading something very deep; you can't fit much into one-and-a-half pages of AP writing space, unless you're a fantastic writer who's mastered concise diction at the age of seventeen. The essay attempts to analyse the book Things Fall Apart and the question "does anything ever stay the same." The author introduces the main character Okonkwo, who stubbornly resists change in his village. There are no specific points of evidence brought up about Okonkwo or his village (other than he's stubborn); the author merely insists that "as time passed, changes began to form" in this village. These changes were apparently caused by "cultural persuasions", though no examples are given. The author attempts to relate back to the question in saying "Achebe's use of cultural changes and development makes the work apprehendable to realize that things do change and never stay the same", but the fact that no examples of cultural persuasions were presented in the essay make this statement irrelevant. Not only this, the author twists "apprehend" into a different form that makes no sense in the context of the sentence. Vague, incorrect diction and simplistic writing such as this appears all throughout the essay, as in "The village of the story during the time period has its difference and consists of contrasting views, opinions and characteristics about life", which make the piece as a whole difficult to read. Due to these errors, I would have to give this essayist a 3 for the work.
Response "N": I was rather impressed with this student's response to the prompt, where he or she used Candide to answer the prompt, which deals with questions raised in literature and how authors answer them. Though the student did tend to summarize quite a bit in the first paragraph, all of the summarizing was relevant to his or her analysis. The student goes into great detail to explain how the central question in Candide, "Is this the best of all possible worlds", is answered and how it relates to the book's meaning. The author tells us of Candide's exploits throughout the book and how he is always unsatisfied with the worlds he encounters, which leads him to the conclusion that "we must tend our garden" when it comes to the world, meaning we all must do what is necessary to keep this world better. The student mainly examines details from the plot, such as Candide's expulsion from his castle, his time spent in war, and his journey to the mythic El Dorado, though she does not do this simply to summarize. With each point the author ties it back to the central question, saying, in the case of El Dorado, that Candide could not reconcile his already-embedded sense of greed and lust in a society where greed and lust did not exist. Though the student does not directly state it, he or she does tie the question and his or her points back to the meaning of the book in the third paragraph, using Candide's answer to the central question to back up the book's point that "we all must strive to make each individual life the best possible." Overall, I would give this student a solid 8, for though he or she did a wonderful job responding to the prompt, there was enough summarizing present to knock it back a point.
Response "J": Compared to the first response, this takes quite a dive in quality of evidence. This essay is about Huckleberry Finn and the question "what does it mean to be free", and the author sets us up for something great, with the opportunity for many specific details, though he or she does not deliver to the fullest extent. The first paragraph is essentially plot summary, with the author telling us how Jim and Huck are both enslaved in different ways and escape on a raft to escape that slavery, but he or she does not attempt to connect with the central question or meaning in any way. In the following paragraphs many attempts to relate details and images from the text to the question are made, but they are all to vague to be concrete. Take the author's point that "When in town or with the 'King' or 'Duke', Huck and Jim must hide their feelings for each other because of society's conventions about race", which addresses an important issue in the book, but doesn't relate the point made back to the question in full. One can discern a skeleton of what this essayist is saying, but it is in no way fleshed out enough to be given a high score. I think a 5 would be an appropriate score for this student.
Response "uu": The sparsity of this essay was an immediate tip-off to the fact that I wasn't going to be reading something very deep; you can't fit much into one-and-a-half pages of AP writing space, unless you're a fantastic writer who's mastered concise diction at the age of seventeen. The essay attempts to analyse the book Things Fall Apart and the question "does anything ever stay the same." The author introduces the main character Okonkwo, who stubbornly resists change in his village. There are no specific points of evidence brought up about Okonkwo or his village (other than he's stubborn); the author merely insists that "as time passed, changes began to form" in this village. These changes were apparently caused by "cultural persuasions", though no examples are given. The author attempts to relate back to the question in saying "Achebe's use of cultural changes and development makes the work apprehendable to realize that things do change and never stay the same", but the fact that no examples of cultural persuasions were presented in the essay make this statement irrelevant. Not only this, the author twists "apprehend" into a different form that makes no sense in the context of the sentence. Vague, incorrect diction and simplistic writing such as this appears all throughout the essay, as in "The village of the story during the time period has its difference and consists of contrasting views, opinions and characteristics about life", which make the piece as a whole difficult to read. Due to these errors, I would have to give this essayist a 3 for the work.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)