"The Ultimate Guide to Writing Better Than You Normally Do" by Colin Nissan
http://www.mcsweeneys.net/articles/the-ultimate-guide-to-writing-better-than-you-normally-do
Finally, some advice about writing I can use! Colin Nissan in this 2012 article from McSweeny's satirizes writers' insatiable desire to become better by offering up some helpful tips; and as we are all writers in this class, I think we can relate to some of the themes and realities he touches on. Nissan effectively communicates his work through syntax, diction and details.
This piece is arranged as if it were some sort of self-help pamphlet, and with each section, the syntax changes to fit the particularities of that part. Take the first section, offering the advice to "write every day", where the syntax is intentionally blunt and disjointed. Only one sentence in this section is of considerable length, while the others are on the shorter side, especially the first, which offers only the blunt statement of "Writing is a muscle." Nissan uses asyndeton in the third sentence to speed its pace along and help it stick in one's head; while the final sentence is technically not a sentence. It's as if we are listening to a personal trainer breaking up a workout routine for us with these quick statements, trying to implant an idea in our heads. Though the third section contains even blunter phrases ("The blank white page"; "El Pollo Loco"), it's syntax is markedly different from the first's in that it includes six questions grouped in threes. This demonstrates the "rule of three", a technique often used to drive home a point or to draw attention to a specific section. Here, it draws the reader in by creating an initial tone of support, as if we were reading a gun-ho self-help sermon: "was Picasso intimidated by the blank canvas? Was
Mozart intimidated by the blank sheet music? Was Edison intimidated by
the blank lightbulb?" Though when Nissan asks the next three questions, the tone is no longer supportive but exposes the reality of this writer's situation, still grouped in the happy three: "Why did I quit my job at TJ Maxx to write full-time? Can/should I eat this entire box of Apple Jacks? Is The Price is Right on at 10 or 11?" Through this syntax, Nissan pokes fun at the obviously struggling writer attempting to get something done.
The diction, like the syntax, varies from section to section, and while it is mostly colloquial there are parts where elevated diction appears. In the second section, about the dangers of procrastination, diction like "alluring siren", "wicked temptress", and "seafaring wench" takes the terms of procrastination to the extreme, a tactic often used in satiric writing. The warning against procrastination is comically intensified by using this diction. Nissan takes on a fear-instilling tone by using the phrases "El Diablo Blanco" (The White Devil) and "El Pollo Loco" (The Crazy Chicken) in the third paragraph, as non-English phrases are sometimes used to generate feelings of fear and unfamiliarity in writing. Though what he is describing is merely a blank piece of paper, taking things to the extreme by using non-English diction again intensifies the affect it has on the reader. Also, the use of non-English words or phrases in satire often points at the pseudo-intellectuality of the speaker, as here he is trying to be elevated. Colloquial diction is found all throughout the piece, but it sticks out occasionally. In the fourth section, the speaker criticizes Mark Twain's statement "Show, don't tell", by saying "Thanks for nothing, Mr. Cryptic." In every day speech, people often make names out of non-nouns to mock or speak sarcastically of someone, and this is exactly what Nissan does here. In the sixth section, Nissan uses the word "literally" and "goddamn" to create a strongly colloquial feel in describing the difficulty of Sudoko. No intellectual writer would use "goddamn" or "literal" offhandedly, and the usage here increases the colloquial tone of the piece.
The details of this piece work to shine a light on a writer's assumed destitute living situation, poking fun at the pre-fame phase of every writer's career where he devotes all his energy to writing. The speaker questions the writer's decision to quit his former job at TJ Maxx and become a writer in the third section. Other details such as eating a box of Apple Jacks and watching The Price is Right all contribute to the feeling that this writer is living a not-so-good life. Those who spend their days watching TV and eating out of boxes of cereal are not generally considered by society to be successful. Other details such as the googling of television characters to put off writing and the "little" house of the writer demonstrate his lack of money and difficulties with writing. It is also implied in the last section that the writer's "demons" are actually psychological disorders in need of treatment; perhaps this implied imbalance of the mind is also poking fun at writing itself, calling it a disorder that drives one to eat boxes of Apple Jacks and the like.
As a writer myself, I know how one can be drawn in by the temptations of procrastination and the fear of the blank page, but like Nissan says, all you have to do is exercise. His wonderful satire of the writer and his struggles is firmly communicated through his usage of varied syntax, colloquial and elevated diction, and details about a writer's life.
Hey Drew!
ReplyDeleteI'm really impressed with this post. You talk about things I didn't even pick up on, such as the effect the use of questions in sets of threes has on this article, and how it helps the author prove his point. This article is fun to read, and the diction, syntax, and details you discuss make it thus. Your analysis of the use of DIDLS in this article is thorough and insightful, and I admire your ability to pick up on so many small but important details in a work of writing. Also, I like your own use of DIDLS (especially imagery) when describing the author's use of DIDLS. It's kinda like DIDL-ception.
Drew, like Syndey, I was also very impressed by your analysis of this article. You did an excellent job of thoroughly describing how the author's use of syntax, details and diction help to strengthen this article. I also like that you chose an article that is so relevant to our class, for I also learned some useful tips about writing so thank you! In your explanation of the syntax you did a great job of showing how he used several different techniques to constantly change the tone of the passage which I find very interesting but completely agree with. You also did a great job pointing out the different types of diction used and provided very good and detailed examples. Overall Drew, this is an excellent analysis and I was really able to get a clear view of what you got form the article, great work!
ReplyDelete