Sunday, April 27, 2014

The Eigth, and Final, Response to Course Material

Like a great army approaching over the horizon, guns and swords glinting in the hot July sun, so looms the AP test, not two weeks away from this date. O! how I shudder to think on it! Our preparations for battle in class over these past few weeks will do us good in the end, once we face that grotesque monster that feeds on the dreams of innocent little high school students.

Ceremony has ended, and Fifth Business has begun. We finished our discussions with the usual theme statement and all the bells and whistles that come along with theme statements, though I still don't feel as much closure as I'd want to. I guess it stemmed from my reading of the book, which I felt went by too quickly, even though I consciously slowed down my pace after I realized that I was covering too much ground without really taking anything from that ground. Silko's writing style just isn't conducive to really ruminative reading in my opinion, and I think that's a big reason as to why the book feels weird and inconclusive when I'm absolutely sure that it has a definite message. And our class was sure of that, too; we got a theme statement on the board, as did all the other hours, so there was definite processing going on. The last peer review period opened my interpretation up to these different theme statements, and they were especially helpful in expanding my grasp of the book, but even so, I don't feel it completely. Maybe I need to go through some sort of ceremony myself. Anyway, Fifth Business has been going splendidly for me, and I'm enjoying it so far. Despite the fact that it was written in 1970, it feels like it was written at the turn of the century; Davies' style is very distinctly older, and if anything it adds to the book's value. I initially thought the book to be semi-autobiographical, though was proven wrong by the stalwart scholars at Wikipedia. Davies' life mirror's his character Dunstan's life in that they are Canadian, their fathers were newspapermen and that they devoured books and eventually became teachers, but Davies' never went to war or got caught up in studying Saints. It still stands as a reflection of Davies' experience with small-town life, though, as he did grow up in the small town of Thamesville, Ontario.

What with Ceremony now gone, we've really been ramping up the AP test preparation. We've done one multiple choice, two essays, one examination of the whole damn test, and worked through some exemplary poetry as of right this moment. I wrote in my last post that I had essentially given up about the whole thing and was leaving it to the whims of fate, but after seeing the whole test in its entirety, I now see it as just another annoying, APUSH or WHAP style affair that I'm just going to have to burn through. I've decried the formatting and general style of the AP test in the past, but doing that obviously isn't getting me anywhere, so I might as well accept the fact that it ain't gonna change. I'm feeling a bit more confident about this test now that I've finally accepted its reality (took me long enough). The 2013 test we took a look at made me even more hopeful, as the multiple choice questions I and several others answered were not too hard, though one of the closed prompts was a doozy, involving two different poems dealing with the same subject. Structuring an essay around two poems would be quite difficult to do in forty short minutes, and I hope that sort of prompt does not befall us this year.

Friday, April 18, 2014

Summary and Analysis of "Ceremony"

Ceremony is a 1977 novel written by Laguna Pueblo author Leslie Marmon Silko. Because the book is non-linear, time and setting change often, though most events take place in or around the Laguna Pueblo reservation sometime after World War II. Other settings include Gallup, New Mexico and the jungles of the Philippines. Ceremony is not structured in the typical Western, linear style; Silko constructs the story by jumping in and out of the present, revisiting older stories, explaining the lives of outlier characters, and interweaving a series of ancient tribal poems that reflect the present and tie the entire bundle together.

Summary:
Ceremony begins with the memories and feelings of the main character, Tayo, a Laguna Pueblo tribesman who served in World War II. He has just returned from a military hospital in Los Angeles where he was being treated for a physical and mental sickness that had overtaken him while fighting in the Philippines. His mind is wracked with pain and guilt: Tayo's de facto brother, Rocky, died in his arms during the war, and the memory of his beloved uncle Josiah is still fresh and brutal. His aunt, called Auntie, is resentful of Tayo for being half-White and half-Native-American; now that he is home, Tayo can no longer ignore the sentiments against him. In a desperate attempt to forget these tragedies and trials, Tayo turns to drinking and the comfort of his friends, namely Harley and Leroy, who often go drinking in the bars lining the highways leading out of the reservation. Tayo and his friends are disillusioned by the prevalence of white culture and wealth that seems to loom over their seemingly poorer society, and often regale each other with tales of sex with white women, treating them like the spoils of the war they all fought in. In an expression of his rage and pain, Tayo stabs one of his more bitter associates, Emo, in the stomach after Emo proclaims his hatred for both the Japanese and White people. Tayo's condition does not improve with time, though, and his grandmother advises him to receive a traditional healing ceremony performed by Ku'oosh, the local medicine man in Laguna. Unfortunately, Ku'oosh does not perform the right ceremony for Tayo because he does not fully understand his condition, though he suggests that Tayo visit Betonie, a mixed-race Navajo medicine man living near Gallup, New Mexico. Tayo goes to visit the man, who suggests a different form of ceremony, one that diverges from the traditions that other medicine men are clinging to. The ceremony is performed on Tayo, but it is not completed; Tayo must do that himself. In this process of completion Tayo must reclaim something that has been taken from him, and that something is a herd of Mexican cattle, tough to the drought that has been sweeping Laguna, that Josiah purchased many years ago but were lost. Tayo goes out into the wilds of New Mexico and eventually finds them, driving them back home. He is aided by the woman T'seh, who represents the earth; and it is through T'seh that Tayo reconnects with the land spiritually and physically. Even though there is a peace surrounding Tayo after he finds the cattle, T'seh advises him to leave the area, in fear that Emo will seek him out, looking to kill. Tayo wanders through the reservation, evading capture, even when Harley and Leroy pick him up and Tayo is momentarily tempted to leave the ceremony behind. Tayo escapes them and goes to a former uranium mine, though Emo and his friends show up. Tayo remains unnoticed, but as Emo begins to savagely beat Harley and eventually kill him, Tayo cannot help himself to be tempted with the desire to kill Emo right there. In the end, this temptation is resisted, and the ceremony is completed, with Tayo being fully healed.

Characters:
Tayo: The main protagonist, a Laguna Pueblo veteran who returns home from World War II with the deaths of his cousin Rocky and his uncle Josiah heavy on his mind. Tayo experiences physical and mental sickness upon his return, and longs for relief. He tries to stifle these feelings with alcohol, though they never leave him, and eventually he begins to turn to traditional Laguna spirituality with the help of old man Ku'oosh and Betonie, two medicine men. Betonie suggests that the old ideas that the older men are entrenched in must be changed in order to survive as a people and as individuals. Tayo has sexual relations with two katsina, or spirits, the Night Swan and T'seh, both of whom lead Tayo onto spiritual regeneration.


Rocky: Rocky is Tayo's cousin and de facto brother, who enlisted with Tayo and died in his arms. We know little about Rocky, though we do see through memories that he was ambitious and driven, winning a football scholarship and determined to leave Laguna. His mother, Auntie, was determined to see her son succeed, and essentially told Tayo to protect Rocky during the war. Because Rocky died in his arms, Tayo feels guilty for his death, as if he could have done something to prevent it.

Auntie: Auntie is Rocky's mother, one of the characters that is determined to accept White culture to a great extent. She is a converted Catholic and often attends church alone, though she remains part of the Laguna community at the same time. Tayo is her nephew, and he is the product of her sister's relationship with a white man; it is this reason that Auntie is wary of Tayo and distances herself and her son from him.

Josiah: Josiah is Auntie's husband and a father figure for Tayo. His cause of death is uncertain and never explained, though it deeply affects Tayo. The resolution of his death is brought about by the ceremonies and the rediscovery of his Mexican cattle, who had been wandering the New Mexican desert for many years. Josiah also had a relationship with a katsina, the Night Swan, who pointed him towards buying the cattle in the first place.

Grandma: She is the mother of Auntie and Tayo's mother, a much older person who embodies much of the old-world traditionalism found in the book. She is the person that recommends that old Ku'oosh come visit Tayo; also the one who sees the flash of light produced by the atomic explosion and recognizes its danger.

Ku'oosh and Betonie: These two characters are medicine men, the former a Laguna Pueblo, the latter a mixed-race Navajo. Ku'oosh performs the first ceremony upon Tayo, but does not fully understand what Tayo needs, so he recommends that Tayo see Betonie, a medicine man regarded for his eccentricity and non-traditional ceremonial practices. It is with Betonie that the main healing ceremony begins in Tayo; and it is Betonie who provides a "map" for the rest of the events in the book, a constellation showing the places and phases of the ceremony that Tayo must undergo.

Harley, Leroy, Pinkie: These three characters are part of the group that Tayo drinks with. They all are representative of the influence White culture has had on Laguna society; they find solace and purpose in alcohol and the drowning out of traditional elements.

Emo: Emo is a "friend" of Tayo's, more of an associate who drinks with him, but also the physical and spiritual representation of a witch. He also feels jealous towards Tayo's mixed heritage; and both praises and decries White culture. He tries to provoke Tayo in any way possible, egging him on by shaking a bag of teeth stolen from a Japanese soldier. This incident pushes Tayo to stab Emo in the belly, though this does not change much for either character. Emo is responsible for the death of Harley and, because of his witchery, much of the evil in the world.

Night Swan and T'seh: Both of these characters are real human beings but katsina, or spirits, as well. They both have sexual relationships with Tayo throughout the course of the book, and play pivotal roles in Tayo's guidance. Night Swan affirms Tayo's involvement in the ceremony and teaches him about the change that must come about if the Laguna people are to survive. T'seh allows Tayo to reconnect with the land both spiritually and physically, as well as aiding him in his search for Josiah's cattle.

Analysis:
In Ceremony, Leslie Marmon Silko suggests that cultural adaptation while retaining boundaries is the only way to promote human unity and avoid the destruction of cultural values. Throughout the novel, Silko repeatedly mediates on the idea of interconnectedness. Very few things in the novel are not related to something else; in fact, I wouldn't be surprised if everything is in some way connected directly and/or indirectly to another part of the novel. The glue that holds the entire modern frame together are the traditional story arcs, told as poems, that are intermingled with the main text. These stories work to highlight the main story and as independent stories, separate but always shadowing, in some way, the present-day plot. This idea is repeated in the characters themselves; Tayo, Night Swan, Betonie, and T'seh are all in some way connected to various other aspects of life surrounding the Laguna Reservation, namely that they are all of mixed-race descent. The cattle as well support this notion, as Josiah planned to breed them with Laguna cattle and produce an animal better suited to life in the drier areas up north of Mexico. Not only are these literal interconnections made, there are many spiritual and metaphorical ones, such as the cattle being part of the land and Tayo representing the sun. With all this interconnectedness, Silko presents the idea that a culture cannot simply sit and demand that it be left alone by outside forces; it must learn how to coexist and connect with those forces, namely, the White people that have encroached on traditional Laguna land. This point is reaffirmed throughout the book, from early on by the Night Swan to the very end by Tayo's completion of the ceremony. Silko emphasizes the fact that even though White culture is destructive, it is not they alone who are to be blamed; there is witchery afoot, represented by Emo and his gang. The witches seek to drive people away from each other and let culture decay, which is seen in the drunkenness of Tayo and his friends at the beginning of the book. Their alcoholism is a sign of that decay, which can be halted, as we see through the healing power of Tayo's ceremony. But the ceremony does not merely lead Tayo back to traditional values; it allows him to accept himself for what he is and realize fully that Whites are not the only problem, that his Laguna brothers and sisters are passively allowing this decay to take place. It is only through this realization that Tayo can be fully healed.

Quotes: 
"He cried the relief he felt at finally seeing the pattern, the way all the stories fit together - the old stories, the war stories, their stories - to become the story that was still being told. He was not crazy; he had never been crazy. He had only seen and heard the world as it always was: no boundaries, only transitions through all distances and time." (Silko, 246)
This quote comes at the end of the novel when Tayo is encamped at the uranium mine and Emo shows up. This is the penultimate realization that is needed to complete the ceremony, the other being the will to resist stabbing Emo. This quote encapsulates many themes Silko explores throughout the novel, mainly the interconnectedness of all things, especially the stories that make up culture. The old stories are constantly being retold, again and again, across the transitions of time, making for a world where boundaries exist, but constantly shift, change, and blend into each other naturally. This is what I believe Silko is driving at with the novel, that transitions across time (long or short), not assimilation or subjugation, are the only way to achieve personal, cultural and human harmony.

"He rubbed his belly / I keep them there / [he said] / Here, put your hand on it / See, it is moving / There is life here for the people. / And in the belly of this story / the rituals and the ceremony / are still growing." (Silko, 2)
To go to the opposite end of the novel, this quote speaks strongly of the nature of culture and the purpose it has for humans. Culture is not a mere human construct that we simply exist in; it is a living, breathing, changing entity, always growing and morphing. This concept is highlighted many times throughout the book, but that fact that it is introduced on the second page speaks of its magnitude. If humans allow themselves and culture to cease growing, then the stories, which ultimately blend into one story, will die off, the culture too, overtaken by something more powerful than itself.

Saturday, March 15, 2014

Response to Course Material #7

Many, many events of certain various natures have transpired in the space of time since last there was assigned a post of this type; and if that wasn't vague or hackneyed enough for you, then I might as well stop trying. Let's see, we finished Rosencrantz and Guildenstern are Dead, began Ceremony, started examining critical lenses, and have had such a fun time doing so. The end of discussion to R&G was a bittersweet one indeed; I greatly enjoyed the play and loved discussing it and hearing the multitude of opinions that were revealed. At the tail end of our discussions the Postmodernist reading of the play was thrown into the blender, and for our class I think it made us accept not writing a classwide theme statement a little easier. The very fact that we did that is kind of surprising, as we'd all become so accustomed to that practice, but the essay really showed my class that differing interpretations were all right and even necessary. Synthesizing the play into one concise theme statement to be agreed upon by all would take away the essential ambiguity of the work, the essayists seemed to be saying, and I think some of us in second hour agreed with this. Sometimes I wrestle with this notion, though, of a work being almost inherently meaningless so an audience can find their own meanings. R&G is far more concrete in meaning than other Postmodern works, but other ones, such as certain Bob Dylan songs, are downright meaningless, and inherently so. Take, for instance, the songs "Stuck Inside of Mobile With the Memphis Blues Again" and "Sad-Eyed Lady of the Lowlands", two songs off of Dylan's 1966 album Blonde on Blonde. Both of these songs rely almost exclusively on bizarre imagery, "poetic" comparisons, and sheer length (go check 'em out; give 'em a listen or read the lyrics, which can be found on this site, dylanchords, or don't do anything, I don't control you). I've been listening to Bob Dylan for most of my life, and have listened to both of these songs a fair number of times; I couldn't tell you anything about their meaning. Not one word. I'm more partial to "Stuck Inside of Mobile", but that's because I like the music more than "Sad-Eyed Lady." Did Dylan intend for these songs to contain clear meaning, or was he, in the style of Jackson Pollack, simply slinging words at a blank page and hoping that someone might be able to figure their meaning out? For if a piece can be interpreted in any manner possible, then isn't it just plain meaningless; and that begs the question, what's the point? Don't get me wrong, I love Bob Dylan's music to an almost inhuman extent, but sometimes when I sit there listening I think to myself "What the hell? What's he getting at?" Those are my main qualms with modern and post-modern art that we deal with on a daily basis in AP Lit.

To change gears, Ceremony has now begun. So far, am I enjoying it; it is quite unlike most of the Native American literature that I've been exposed to over the years. Yeah, I took American lit; I saw Smoke Signals, and frankly, I detested it, but Silko is not Alexie, and Ceremony is certainly not Smoke Signals. After reading Silko's essays on her own cultural experience, Ceremony has become quite an intense work to read, almost an exhausting one. The huge range of emotions expressed, from cathartic joy to the most extreme lows of fear and anxiety take their toll on the reader, not to mention the jumping and skipping between narrative voices and time periods; it's hard to comprehend all at once. If I hadn't read Silko's essays, the narrative flow would have made no sense, but after reading that in Pueblo culture a story cannot be explained just by itself; a virtual history must be included for it to make any sense. As of writing this, I'm about two-thirds into the book, and I cannot yet see a resolution to Tayo's internal grief. I'm looking forward to discussing this work; I've heard many terrible things about it from previous AP students, and so far they've all been untrue for me, but I'm sure there's somebody out there this year that doesn't like this book. As I've been reading, one story so similar to Tayo's keeps coming back, the story of Ira Hayes, who is immortalized in the song written by Peter LaFarge about his life ("The Ballad of Ira Hayes"; here's a good version Townes Van Zandt; Ira Hayes). Ira Hayes was a member of the Arizona Pima tribe and was one of the flag-raisers in the famous photograph taken atop Iwo Jima. He was a decorated soldier, a war hero, and even appeared in a film with John Wayne, but he fell into a pattern of alcoholism and depression close to the one Silko explores in her novel. Hayes was never comfortable with his fame, and died of exposure after a night of drinking ten years after his famous contribution to World War II. Now, I am not Hayes, I cannot see into his mind, wherever it may be, but I feel that he experienced much of the same detachment and alienation that Tayo did after the war ended. Perhaps Silko had the story of Hayes in the back of her mind when she wrote this book, along with all of her own stories and experiences, but there is certainly a clear connection.

Critical lenses was, strangely enough, something I didn't expect to encounter in AP Lit. Now, that is a quite a silly thought, considering critical lenses are about the biggest thing to consider when interpreting any work of literature, but I'm just a silly teenager who doesn't think about things. The powerpoint and lecture that we saw were both quite revealing, for I knew a vague outline of varying critical lenses from my American Lit days, though these two materials explained them in greater detail and showed some of the history behind them. Of course we all loved the dancing urinal. There's no question that we didn't, but I'm finding the current discussions on all the works we've read this year when put under those lenses a bit more stimulating (though we should all get black bodysuits and carve urinal headgear and wear it to the AP test). Unfortunately, I haven't been to AP Lit very much over the past few days of discussions, so I've missed much of what was said.

Lastly, let's talk about AP essays. Honestly, I don't know what I'm going to do any more. I spent over two hours going over the most recent closed prompt revision, pretty much tearing it down to the roots and reconstructing something more coherent. The test allows for forty minutes. Oh poop. Strangely enough, I'm not that frightened about the thing, despite only being two months away. Maybe I should become frightened. It might make cause me to write better. Or seize up. One of the two. Fifty-fifty chance, and we all know what happens when people deal with the same side of two coins...

Sunday, March 9, 2014

Open Prompts! Hurray!

2009. A symbol is an object, action, or event that represents something or that creates a range of associations beyond itself. In literary works a symbol can express an idea, clarify meaning, or enlarge literal meaning. Select a novel or play and, focusing on one symbol, write an essay analyzing how that symbol functions in the work and what it reveals about the characters or themes of the work as a whole. Do not merely summarize the plot.

In Tom Stoppard's Rosencrantz and Guildenstern are Dead, one of the work's major motifs is the boat the two titular characters travel on when taking Hamlet to England. The symbol functions as a representation of the lives of the two main characters, as well as the direction towards death that all humans are headed in. The boat-symbol helps reveal the theme of the work, that theme being that even though humans have a perception of free will, their lives are dictated by forces stronger than an individual's.

We see, in act three of Stoppard's work, that the lives of Rosencrantz and Guildenstern are represented by the boat and its inability to be controlled by the two main characters. Much of the play's preceding text has focused on the confusion and anxiety the two have experienced waiting around for their cues in a production of Hamlet, and this trend continues on the boat, where the only remaining cue left by Shakespeare is their deaths, which is mentioned in passing at the very end of the play. The two have been predestined to die since the beginning of the play, but it is only until they get on the boat that they begin to realize that their deaths are imminent. Like the boat, the lives of Rosencrantz and Guildenstern are being steered by someone other than themselves, namely Stoppard and Shakespeare, who have both written in their different plays that the two must die. Though Guildenstern says in this act that the two are free to move about and do what they please, the must do it within the physical limitations of the boat, and therefore have no real free will because they do not control the force that is driving them onwards. One can take this realization purely on the surface, and if one does, it appears that Stoppard is claiming that life is out of our hands. Humanity is all upon a boat, and it is captained by the constructs that determine who we are and what we do: culture, power, money, etc. Individuals cannot control these grand ideas, and must relegate themselves to movement within the boat.

The boat is obviously going somewhere; in the literal case, to England, but if the boat represents life, then the direction it is heading in is death. This fact is acknowledged over and over by both Rosencrantz and Guildenstern as well as the Player, who foreshadows the two's demise in the second act. In the third act, death is a mainstay of conversation: the two awake on a dark stage and postulate that they might, in fact, be dead at that moment, but the lights come up to reveal that they aren't. Guildenstern argues with the Player about how "real" death is truly incomprehensible, quite unlike the thousands of stage deaths that the Player has died over the years. Within much of the anxious, confused conversation regarding death, there is a brief moment of clarity where Guildenstern quotes Socrates, saying that since humans no nothing of death, it is illogical to fear it. This quote does not aid in the two's coping with death, especially after the letters have been switched by Hamlet to truly cement the deaths of the twosome. At the very end of the play there is a glimmer of acceptance by the two that shows their complacency with their uncontrollable lives and the boat leading them on towards death. Stoppard seems to be saying that it is not pertinent to fight the boat or its course, because both are out of a single person's control. Rosencrantz and Guildenstern have talked of escaping the confines of the stage before in the play, but they cannot escape the confines of the play's ending, much as humans cannot escape the confines of their deaths. Even the grand concepts of culture and power and money, all of which can dictate the lives of millions of people, lead humans in the same basic direction. 

The symbol of the boat in Rosencrantz and Guildenstern are Dead helps the reader of Stoppard's work to better understand one of the large themes being explored in the play. The boat, representing life and the direction towards death, is controlled by a higher force, and despite the confusion and anxiety that this causes for Rosencrantz and Guildenstern, the two are still caged by its power, like the rest of humanity.

Thursday, March 6, 2014

Summary and Analysis of "Rosencrantz and Guildenstern are Dead"

Rosencrantz and Guildenstern are Dead was written by British playwright Tom Stoppard in 1966. The play owes many debts to other works, some more obvious than others, including William Shakespeare's Hamlet and Samuel Beckett's Waiting for Godot, Hamlet being the source of the title, characters, and several scenes in Stoppard's work.

The play is set on a blank stage, though the setting changes to the castle of Elsinore and a boat, signaled by lighting and sound changes only. Seldom are large set pieces used in a production of this play; the stage is supposed to be as blank and featureless as possible.

Stoppard's play, while seemingly absurd in nature and structure, is very tightly composed, with many considerations being taken towards the use of specific language, puns, and wordplay to create multiple meanings. While the play itself has no "voice", a strong sense of the malleability and ambiguity of language is present throughout, creating a certain unique pattern of speech that permeates the conversations of the two main characters. The diction is often colloquial unless the two main characters are present in a scene from Hamlet, where elevated diction is employed.

PLOT: The play opens with our two titular characters aimlessly flipping coins on an empty stage. The coins are all turning up heads, and Guildenstern is unsettled by this constant occurrence, and attempts to explain it with logic and reason, though the explanations he gives are wordy and hackneyed. Rosencrantz is not struck by this, and the two continue until a troupe of actors, travelling in a wagon, appears and is delighted by their presence. They wish to act out a play for the two, though it soon becomes apparent that what they are really selling is sex. Guildenstern understands immediately, but Rosencrantz, unaware of this, eggs the leader of the troupe on until he nearly purchases a "private showing." Guildenstern is disgusted by the Player and his lackeys, though the Player shrugs it off. The scene then changes, signaled only by a lighting shift, to Elsinore, the nucleus of Denmark. Our titular characters are again lost in a blank stage, occasionally populated by the characters of Hamlet. To pass the time, Rosencrantz and Guildenstern play another game, a question game, where the two simply volley questions back and forth like a game of tennis. While waiting around, Claudius and Gertrude encounter the two and give them their orders to discover what afflicts Hamlet, though this proves to be a difficult process. The two discuss various ways of going about the process, though whenever they actually speak to Hamlet they are at a loss for "probing" words. Hamlet figures their duties out and refuses to trust them, and the two are now truly at a loss for what to do. Meanwhile, the Players have arrived at Elsinore and are rehearsing the play they are to perform for Hamlet, which is essentially a reworking of Hamlet, and clearly outlines the eventual deaths of Rosencrantz and Guildenstern. The two do not understand, and continue on with the play. Claudius then approaches them and informs them that they will be taking Hamlet to England, and the play transitions again, though the stage does not change, save for the addition of three barrels. The two discuss the purpose of the mission, and by accident discover, via a letter given by Claudius, that Hamlet is to die upon arrival. Hamlet, overhearing this, switches the real letter with a letter of his own, condemning Rosencrantz and Guildenstern to death in his stead. And suddenly, pirates attack the boat, and Hamlet escapes, leaving Rosencrantz and Guildenstern alone with the Players, who have revealed themselves to be stowaways. The Player attempts to convince Rosencrantz and Guildenstern that their deaths are inevitable and that they should stop looking for "answers" or "direction", and in the end, the two do accept it, and, off stage, die.

CHARACTERS:
Rosencrantz and Guildenstern: I have decided to lump these two characters into the same description, as Stoppard provides few character notes on them. They often function, as Stoppard would say, as "two sides of the same coin", though the two sides are easily interchangeable. Rosencrantz is characterized as the "dumber" of the two, not inclined to the philosophical postulating of Guildenstern, though there are moments when he does engage in that sort of thought. Guildenstern, conversely, is thoughtful and determined to crack the code of the world, though he never gets close. For instance, in the beginning scenes when the two are spinning coins, Guildenstern considers multiple angles for the cause of why the coins are always landing on heads, but never arrives at a stable conclusion. He can also become like Rosencrantz in a sense, ditching the philosophy of earlier scenes and going for a bluntness of speech uncharacteristic of him. Stoppard intends the two to be interchangeable; and in some productions, the actors playing the characters switch roles halfway through the play. To Stoppard, it seems that the characters of Rosencrantz and Guildenstern from Shakespeare's Hamlet are two typical every-men caught up in the machinations of events greater than themselves, and are therefore confused and anxious about the world around them.

The Player(s): This grouping not only includes the main Player, the head of the travelling acting troupe that our two main characters encounter in the beginning of the play, but also his band of actors, which include musicians and a small boy named Alfred. The Player is the most self-conscious character of them all, seeming to possess a special understanding of the world around him. And indeed, he does: he understands to a great extent that he exists only in a production of Rosencrantz and Guildenstern, which in turn could be thought about existing only in the wings of a production of Hamlet. The Player demonstrates his knowledge of Shakespeare's play and Rosencrantz and Guildenstern's fate when the troupe rehearses The Murder of Gonzago in front of them and essentially plots out the twosome's fate. He also speaks of the audience very self-consciously, and even mocks and criticizes them and their tastes in art. Despite his knowledge, the Player knows that he is bound by Stoppard's written direction and dialogue and understands that he has no power to escape. Because of this, he often advises that Rosencrantz and Guildenstern cease their worrying and simply go along with the action. The rest of his troupe is composed of a band of musicians/actors who are often heard playing in the background or thought to be heard. There is also a small boy named Alfred who, like the others, is prostituted as part of the act. Essentially, the troupe functions as a travelling whorehouse, selling entertainment in the form of highly emotive, sexual plays and sexual acts themselves. Both Rosencrantz and Guildenstern are horrified by this, but the Player king brushes off their incredulity with a dry "times being as they are...."

The Characters of Hamlet - Hamlet, Claudius, Gertrude, Polonious, Ophelia, various Courtiers, etc.: Stoppard places the characters who were at the forefront of Shakespeare's in the wings of his own, and they function essentially as they would in a production of Hamlet. Generally, they are used to underline the confusion surrounding the two main character's of Stoppard's play: Claudius, Gertrude, and Hamlet all confuse one for the other at some point during the play, and usually this results in the humor of either Rosencrantz bowing when Guildenstern is being addressed, or vice-versa. Hamlet is the only Shakespearean character that we see doing things other than what is written. We actually see his passionate display to Ophelia in the closet that is merely described in Hamlet, we see his trip to England on the boat, and we see him aimlessly wandering around Elsinore waiting for one of Shakespeare's cues. In this manner, we see the character of Hamlet, like Rosencrantz and Guildenstern, simply waiting around for some kind of stimulus to respond to, though his philosophical questions are kept out of sight by Stoppard. Hamlet does acknowledge the audience once by spitting into it, though this is the only time he refers to those watching the play.

ANALYSIS
Rosencrantz and Guildenstern are Dead is a particularly difficult play to interpret concretely and one that actively resists absolute meaning; one could derive multiple meanings from even the simplest of passages. Because of this, I found that writing one overarching theme statement would severely limit my thinking about this play, so I shall include two.

Tom Stoppard's Rosencrantz and Guildenstern are Dead suggests that personal control is out of reach and that humans are subject to forces beyond our control. Much of the play revolves around our main character's confusion and anxiety in regards to what they should do about their situation. They do not understand why they are on a stage initially, and even after they have been given Claudius's command they act just as confused. The two have no sense of direction, either literal or metaphorical; they have no sense of their past and have no sense of what is to come, despite the constant foreshadowing of the much wiser Player. Guildenstern often contemplates philosophy and logic, though in this seemingly logic-less word, he never gets any closer to discovering truth. The two are essentially being buffeted about by the winds of Hamlet, a story where great pillars of human beings battle each other in a quest towards truth. Rosencrantz and Guildenstern are mere motes of men, caught up in something bigger than themselves and unable to control the situation. Much of what the Player has to say about the two's constant blubbering about direction and purpose is matter-of-fact and unsympathetic: "Relax. Respond. That's what people do" he says to Guildenstern about their situation (Stoppard, 66). The Player is the main source for the "out-of-control" hypothesis; he gives no solutions to the twosome's directionless existence, but tells them that events are out of their control and they should "go with the flow." It is with these lines that Stoppard comments on humans and their condition in the world. They are the subjects of machinations far greater than themselves: war, power struggles, politics, money, culture, etc., and can essentially do nothing about the big picture. And, because these things are creations of humans, they too are headed in the same direction as the humans themselves: death. The whole of humanity is aboard a "boat", and the boat is going towards the one final certainty, the inevitable end, etc. Now, that is not necessarily a bad thing, to die, and I don't think Stoppard wants us to consider it as a bad thing. We may have no direction in life other than towards death; others may attempt to control us for their own devices; and there may be no overarching meaning to existence. I believe that this play wants us to cease worrying about such things and simply relax and respond to what comes our way.

Tom Stoppard's Rosencrantz and Guildenstern are Dead does provide a typical realization of truth or the human condition as many literary works attempt to do. Rather than answering questions, Stoppard actively questions the social and cultural constructs of the time and provides his own questions for the audience's consideration. Throughout this play, the stage is left intentionally blank by Stoppard in the stage directions. I see this blank, featureless stage, as well as the metaphors of the box and the boat used later in the play, as a representation of culture, namely the culture that Stoppard lived and wrote in. That culture would be the world of the 1960s, a time of extreme social and political upheaval around the globe; a time when postmodern ideas developed and culture began to shift towards the consumer, rather than the creation of a shared identity and story between humans. The same culture exists today in slightly different forms. The emptiness of the stage represents the emptiness of that culture, an emptiness that Stoppard examines further with the Player. This actor once played the great works of literature, but has been forced by the times to prostitute himself and his troupe out to make ends meet. As well as the stage, the box and the boat are two important cultural metaphors employed by Stoppard. In one scene, Rosencrantz begins actively thinking about death and what it would be like, and envisions himself, alive, trapped in a coffin. He reasons that life in a box would be better than no life at all, by the virtue of being alive. In using this device, Stoppard seems to be acknowledging that culture (the box) determines the importance of a person and their existence; without it, life would be pointless. Though I believe that Stoppard wants us to step outside of this viewpoint, "step outside of the box", per say, and consider our lives outside of cultural influence. The same goes for the boat metaphor used in the third act. Rosencrantz and Guildenstern are anxious about their direction and what they are supposed to do, and they do have an objective, written purpose set down by Stoppard and Shakespeare in this play and Hamlet. But humans do not function like characters in works of literature, especially in this play. Stoppard has created a work with an on-the-surface message about the lack of real control in the lives of ordinary humans, though he really wants us to consider what life would be like without the personal, cultural, or worldwide boxes, boats, and stages that humans create and place themselves in. The titular characters speak of leaving the stage several times, though they cannot do it, because they are bound by a higher power, Stoppard's words. Are we? Are humans truly imprisoned by the limitations of culture, money, power, etc., or can we step outside of those constructs and begin to consider life differently?

(Note: I do believe that both of these interpretations are equally credible, though personally I am more partial to the second. I understand that the second interpretation is highly speculative and relies on little textual evidence, which is the main reason I would use the first in an essay-writing situation.)

QUOTES
"PLAYER: For some of us it is performance, for others, patronage. They are two sides of the same coin, or, let us say, being as there are so many of us, the same side of two coins." (Stoppard, 23)
This quote exemplifies much of the manipulation of language and self-awareness that the play possesses. Contextually, the Player is speaking to Rosencrantz, though he directly addresses the audience in the second part of the quote. This practice is repeated several times, and in doing such outlandish things as speaking to an audience during the production, Stoppard creates a stage that no longer separates performers from patrons, bringing art onto the level of people who are not artists. This concept, along with other hallmarks of postmodernism, are found throughout the play. Stoppard's commentary on art is, like the work itself, subject to much interpretation; one could cite quotes supporting the notion that art should never have been taken down from its pedestal. The quote presented here could be used to support the idea that art should be brought to that level.

"GUILDENSTERN: Where we went wrong was getting on a boat. We can move, of course, change direction, rattle about, but our movement is contained within a larger one that carries us along as inexorably as the wind and current." (Stoppard, 122)
This quote, like the previous one, contains multiple meanings, a hallmark of the work in general. It could be taken as allegorical, with the boat representing life and/or culture and the words a simple, on-the-surface statement about the condition of humans in this world today. Though, if examined a different way, the reader could take Stoppard to mean that life is not a reflection of the caged existence Rosencrantz and Guildenstern possess in this play. This same duality of interpretation, present throughout much of the play in forms such as the quote above, creates much confusion and hair-tussling for the thoughtful reader trying to crack into Stoppard's meanings. Though that may be what Stoppard wants us to do, agonize over passages such as this only to realize that objective meaning is not present in the quote or the work in general. This quote is more direct that some that lie in the same vein, but its meaning still lies in how one perceives it.

Sunday, February 9, 2014

In Response to an Open Prompt

2003: According to critic Northrop Frye, “Tragic heroes are so much the highest points in their human landscape that they seem the inevitable conductors of the power about them, great trees more likely to be struck by lightning than a clump of grass. Conductors may of course be instruments as well as victims of the divisive lightning.” Select a novel or play in which a tragic figure functions as an instrument of the suffering of others. Then write an essay in which you explain how the suffering brought upon others by that figure contributes to the tragic vision of the work as a whole. 


When we first meet the character of Hamlet, it is uncertain as to what he will do about the Claudius-Gertrude debacle that has consumed his life and taken him from his collegiate studies. But once he receives the ghost’s command to exact revenge on a treacherous brother, Hamlet’s actions become unfocused and wild, the opposite of what one would expect to happen. In this wildness, he cuts down many before him, though he never reaches the king himself until the end. Firstly, he begins with Ophelia, who he debases with harsh speech and claims that she is a whore after his “To be, or not to be” soliloquy. This begins Ophelia’s downward spiral, continued further by the murder of her father, Polonius. Eventually, Ophelia, who may also be pregnant with Hamlet’s child, can take no more of the strife she has to deal with and commits suicide, while remaining mainly innocent in regards to the affairs of Elsinore. Polonius, too, is cut down by Hamlet, though his involvement with Claudius does link him directly to the continued corruption and treachery in Denmark. Polonius is frequently ridiculed by Hamlet in passing, and Hamlet demonstrates no sorrow in killing Polonius accidentally. Rosencrantz and Guildenstern are treated not as friends but as spies; Hamlet makes no attempt to try and win them over to his side, instead sending them to their deaths cold-heartedly. Hamlet treats his mother with less than kindness and inadvertently leads to her death at the end of the play, when Claudius’s plot backfires on him. And at the end of the play, when all the main players are dead, Hamlet gives the gutted kingdom of Denmark over to Norway, who was merely passing through, handing the control of its citizens over a foreigner that once warred against them. Hamlet never succeeds in efficiently killing his target, Claudius, who dies only out of the convenience of the situation at the play’s end.


As the play unfolds, we see that Hamlet’s inability to act quickly and efficiently stems from an identity crisis. Hamlet is supposed to be nothing more than a carbon-copy of his father, a violent, uncompromising leader that would go into battle to defend his kingdom at any cost. We see that Hamlet thinks nothing like this: he is contemplative, inquisitive, and in a sense, very new-age, as he has absorbed many Protestant ideals from his studies in Wittenberg. He is a Renaissance man grappling with the ideas of a past that he rejects, a past that is ever-present and ever-influential in his life. This is this reason that Hamlet destroys so much in the course of this play; he cannot reconcile himself with his surroundings. And, in turn, this compromises all of Hamlet’s moral judgment, leading him to hurt and kill those around him, whether he wants to or not. This leaves us readers with Shakespeare’s warning that a confused identity results in the compromise of morality, and that this may lead to catastrophic results, especially for such a large character as Hamlet.

We learn much from Shakespeare’s works today; his command of the English language and the ideas that accompany them have proved themselves timeless again and again. It is messages such as the ones accompanying Hamlet that keep people coming back to them, for we all have experienced identity crises at one point or another, and have felt their effects on our minds and bodies. Hamlet never intended to cause so much pain when he received the ghost’s order; he was paralyzed by his surroundings and could not escape. His stature was so large that in his fall from grace, he took a seemingly impossible number of people with him.