2009 Question 3
Student 3A: This student's response to Henrik Ibsen's The Wild Duck does a more-than-adequate job of answering the prompt on symbols. While at times the author does tend to summarize the plot, he or she almost always relates it back to the prompt. The symbol of analysis here is the titular duck, which represents many facets of the characters. The student clearly shows us what the symbol relates to ("[the duck] comes to symbolize the family's tranquility and happiness", "the symbol of the wild duck is used to represent the family's innocence and happiness", etc.) and when, using the context of the plot to do so. However, I do not think so highly of this author's thesis, which was rather vague: ". . . Ibsen uses an overarching symbol of a wild duck in order to highlight the events and development of characters throughout." This thesis made it difficult to navigate through the body, as each section did not clearly relate to a part of the thesis. Overall, I would give this student an 8, for the essay was good, but the thesis and structure needed tending to.
Student 3B: This student's response to Tennessee Williams' A Streetcar Named Desire lacked an extremely clear focus as to what the main symbol, a lampshade, accomplished in the play. While it was clear, it was not clear enough to award this student anything higher than a 6. This student actually speaks more of revealing the truth, rather than the hiding of it, as the latter is what the lampshade seems to accomplish in this play. The majority of the third paragraph, for example, outlines Blanche's exposure of truth, the truth being that her first husband was gay. Only in the last sentence ("she began a pattern of hiding what's real") does the author address the actual meaning of the symbol, and he or she does not clearly relate it back to lampshades. Plot summary is also used extensively, though it has more of a purpose in the third paragraph than the second; it is merely superfluous in the latter. This student's flaws in his or her essay are not enough to cause it to plummet into the depths of threes and twos, though they are quite apparent.
Student 3C: This student's response to Things Fall Apart was focused on a symbol present, a machete, though it lacked any complexity of argument and evidence. The author claims that the machete represents "power and strength", which is clearly stated in the thesis, though much of the evidence presented is unrelated to the thesis, such as "[the white men] were converting his family and friends to Christianity" and his assertion that women do not carry machetes. It is very hard to make sense of this essay, as the author offers no concrete evidence. The sentence structure is also very simplistic, with almost every single one being extremely blunt and declarative. The conclusion also does very little concluding: the author asserts that the main character would not "be who he was" without the machete, but does not relate that point back to any evidence in his body or the text, and looking at the body there is very little there to support that point. The only reason I would give this essay a four would be that it is not incomprehensible, and that there is at least an attempt to relate evidence back to the thesis.
Drew,
ReplyDelete3A I agree with your analysis, and I also probably would give this student an 8. It lacks concision, especially in the first two sentences, and it gets a little caught up in summary, but it has some really insightful ideas. I also agree with your comment on the weak thesis. The essay would improve a lot if the thesis were a little more focused.
3B I actually thought the student responded to the prompt pretty thoroughly, and thought it deserved higher than a 6, despite it's getting a little caught up in summary. I would be careful when saying things like "...does the author address the actual meaning of the symbol". Symbols can have multiple meanings, and there can be different interpretations of them. I totally agree with your disagreement with the student, but I think you could have worded it a little differently. Overall though nice response.
3C: I agree completely with your thoughts on this essay. It does have a clear thesis, but the supporting evidence is just not fully there. Also, it only touches on the pride aspect of the thesis, despite it's claim that "most of all, [the machete] symbolizes pride". Overall it's hard to follow and simplistic, with a weak conclusion. You do a nice job of putting the flaws and successes of the essay into words.
Drew, you did a great job critiquing of these students essays and show that you are clearly on the right track to scoring high on the AP exam! You clearly identify what is wrong and lacking in each essay and even give a fair score for each. I also agree that 3A would deserve an 8, for I feel summaries are an often mistake that students tend to do, however the rest of the essay was very strong in explaining the theory. 3B I thought was a decent essay, however I agree that it could have done a better job giving supportive evidence and a better explanation to why they believed the lampshade was the main symbol, however I don't think it would be fair to say they did say the "actual meaning of the symbol" for as Ms. Holme's has mentioned, in literature there is no exact or right answer to symbols or themes. In 3C I think this essay lacked good organization and supportive examples. You did a great job of giving an explanation as to why each student did a good or poor job in this essay, great work!
ReplyDelete