Friday, January 31, 2014

Summary and Analysis of "Hamlet"



PLOT SUMMARY
                Hamlet begins with two guards keeping watch outside of Elsinore; Horatio, a friend of Hamlet’s is also present. They are there to convince Horatio of a ghost that has been appearing in the shape of Prince Hamlet’s dead father, and during the course of the night the ghost does appear, though it does not speak. The next day, the Danish royalty hold court, and Claudius, old Hamlet’s brother and Denmark’s new king, publicly insults Hamlet for grieving too long over his father’s death, and refuses Hamlet’s request to return to Wittenberg, where he has been attending school. After the courtiers leave, Hamlet is approached by Horatio, who tells him of the ghost; they plan to meet the figure that night. Meanwhile, Laertes, the son of an adviser to the king, Polonius, prepares to depart to France. He advises his sister, Ophelia, to stay away from Hamlet, whom she is engaged romantically with. Polonius advises the same to her, though Ophelia strongly implies to him that she and Hamlet are engaged to be married. Later that night, Hamlet and Horatio stalk the grounds for the ghost, and it appears, beckoning Hamlet away. He follows, and the ghost reveals itself to be the spirit of his father, here to deliver a message of vengeance: kill the one who killed me, which would be Claudius, the new king. Hamlet resolves that he must avenge his father’s murder. The next day, the king and queen seek out Rosencrantz and Guildenstern, two courtiers and friends of Hamlet, to try and spy on the Prince and discover the source of his erratic behavior. Hamlet soon finds out their ulterior motives and refuses to trust them. Meanwhile, players arrive at the castle at Hamlet’s request, and he experiences great twinges of doubt about his mission. He hatches a plan, though, to confirm the ghost’s story, by putting on a play wherein a character is murdered in the same fashion as his father; Claudius’ reaction will convict him. And indeed it does convict him, for during the play he leaves, distempered, after the player king is slain. Before this scene, though, Polonius and Claudius devise a plan to discover the source of Hamlet’s discontent, wherein the two will spy on a conversation between Hamlet and Ophelia. Hamlet delivers his most famous speech, where he contemplates suicide and questions his motives; Ophelia enters, and Hamlet soon realizes that he is being watched. His behavior becomes increasingly volatile during the conversation, insulting Ophelia and running off. After all this, including the play, Claudius exposes his thoughts of guilt to us, and kneels down to pray for forgiveness, when Hamlet runs into him, thinks of killing him, but does not, resolving to do so at a time where his actions are not so holy. He is then called into his mother’s chamber, where Polonius hides behind a curtain, and confronts Gertrude about the quickness of remarriage and charges her with incest. Polonius gives himself away, and Hamlet kills him behind the curtain, believing it to be Claudius. The King decides that he’s had enough, and orders Hamlet to go to England, while secretly ordering Rosencrantz and Guildenstern to deliver the orders to the English to kill Hamlet. While going to port Hamlet encounters the army of Fortinbras, the king of Norway, on a conquest mission to Poland; Hamlet resolves there to think nothing but bloody thoughts until his mission is complete. While journeying overseas, Ophelia, distraught over her father’s death and Hamlet’s leave, becomes increasingly erratic in behavior, talking nonsense and singing sexual songs that imply that she is pregnant with Hamlet’s child. She cannot be helped by the court, and commits suicide by drowning herself. Hamlet now returns to Denmark, after his ship is overrun by pirates and having switched the death orders onto their deliverers, and runs into gravediggers digging Ophelia’s grave outside Elsinore. Here he comes face-to-face with death, as the sexton purges the grave of Yorick, the court’s old jester, whom Hamlet loved dearly and treated as a father in his youth. Ophelia’s funeral procession also intersects with this, and Hamlet, in a rage of emotion, jumps into her grave and grapples with Laertes. The two break apart but agree to settle their score with a duel, which Claudius uses to try and kill Hamlet with a poisoned sword or drink. Before the battle, Hamlet resolves his conflicts by giving his life over to God’s ultimate command. Laertes and Hamlet duel, and Hamlet is struck with the poisoned sword. Their weapons become switched at one point, and Hamlet then wounds Laertes with the weapon. Gertrude mistakenly drinks the poisoned wine; and Laertes reveals Claudius’s involvement in the plot. Hamlet forces Claudius to drink the rest of the wine, and he dies, along with Laertes. Hamlet then gives up command of the kingdom to Fortinbras, and dies.

CHARACTERS
Hamlet: He is the current prince of Denmark, the son of old Hamlet, who was the previous king. For most of his life Hamlet’s father was away in battle, and he was brought up mainly by the court’s jester, Yorick. Before the death of his father, Hamlet was away in Wittenberg, Germany, attending university, where he absorbed many Protestant values, as the city was the center of the Reformation. This absorption of ideas and the conflict between older, Catholic ones forms the basis for the play’s religiousness. Throughout the play Hamlet’s mind is wracked with indecision and existential conflict, preventing him from effectively fulfilling his father’s demand to kill his murderer, Claudius. Hamlet, despite his varied and extreme emotions, is often a calculated, nuanced thinker, able to respond to many circumstances that threaten his life. For much of the play he adopts a cloak of madness, though whether or not this madness is inherent or assumed is a matter of great debate. There are instances where he clearly states he is putting on a show for deception, though his actions often seem far more intense than if someone were merely acting. In the end, Hamlet gives up his internal and external conflicts and resigns himself to Providence; he is killed by the hand of Laertes, who blamed Hamlet for the death of Ophelia. 

Claudius: The brother of old Hamlet, as well as his murderer, Claudius usurped the throne of Denmark and took his brother’s wife for his own. It is implied that the two began an affair during old Hamlet’s lifetime, and its continuation into legal marriage was one of the driving forces behind Claudius’s action. In many scenes, he is found to be articulate and cunning, even going so far as to insult Hamlet’s manhood publicly in court, though we do see guilt in him when he kneels down to pray. Claudius’s action remains the most tangible instance of usurpation and corruption within the play.

Gertrude: She is the wife of old Hamlet and the current wife of Claudius. We initially see her as a benevolent, harmless person, though Hamlet immediately brings up the issue of their marriage as incestuous in the Catholic Church. Throughout the play she offers very little insight into her personage; most of what we know about her stems from the “Closet Scene”, where Hamlet denounces her actions in marrying Claudius. She says that upon looking into her soul she sees such “black and grained spots” that will not disappear. Her guilt, however, is not as pronounced as Claudius’s is; and neither of them do much to try and resolve their guilt. 

The Ghost: This character is revealed to be the spirit of old Hamlet, who walks the night to deliver his command of vengeance to Hamlet. The biggest debate about this character revolves around whether or not his spirit is demonic or not. The ghost speaks as if he were in Purgatory, though Hamlet’s indecision to act shows his uncertainty of the figure’s purity. The command of the ghost is also the source of much of the religious questioning in the play, as the conflict arises within Hamlet of whom he must follow, God, who decries vengeance, or his father, who Hamlet feels great duty towards. In the end, though, we, along with Hamlet, discovers that old Hamlet was never really a father to Hamlet, as he was often away fighting. Hamlet then gives his life up to Providence, essentially forgetting his duty to his father.

Horatio: He is by far the most trusted and reliable character in this play. Horatio is the one first approached
by the frightened guards to confirm the existence of the ghost, and he is the one whom Hamlet trusts the most, revealing all of his plans and actions to in earnest. Horatio is so trusted because of his selfless loyalty to others, namely Hamlet; he nearly follows him to the grave to demonstrate his loyalty. He never gives away Hamlet’s secrets either, and never double-crosses Hamlet by going to the King and Queen. He is also by far the most moral and level-headed thinker, especially near the end, when he senses that something will go wrong in the duel and advises Hamlet not to go. Horatio is an almost Paul-like figure to Hamlet’s Christ-like qualities; he is told to warn the world of Hamlet’s downfall, much as Paul was told by Christ to spread his ministry throughout the world.

Polonius: He the closest advisor to King Claudius, and the father of Ophelia and Laertes. Polonius’s most apparent characteristic is his witty, embellished use of diction, which is right in step with the style that courtiers were supposed to use at the time. There are several times throughout the play where his diction becomes so pompous and inflated that other characters tell him to speak in simpler terms. Even though Polonius is a master of courtier-speak, he often speaks with very little substance, and is rarely taken seriously by other characters. He often thinks in political terms and of himself and how he can promote himself and his children to higher places in court. Unlike Claudius, Polonius believes the cause of Hamlet’s erratic behavior stems from his love for Ophelia; he never wavers from this opinion. Hamlet slays Polonius in a case of mistaken identity during the “Closet Scene”, where he assumes the man behind the curtain is Claudius.

Ophelia: Ophelia is the daughter of Polonius and the lover of Hamlet, who often finds herself caught up in things much larger than her relationship with Hamlet. Despite being warned of courting Hamlet, Ophelia continues to see him, until a strange display of affection is put on by Hamlet and she is confused and frightened. The two effectively end their relationship when Hamlet discovers that they’re being spied on by Claudius, and in a fit of rage denounces her as a whore. Ophelia’s emotions and actions act as a foil to the level-headed Gertrude’s. By the end of the play Ophelia has essentially been shattered by circumstance, reeling from the loss of both her lover and her father. There is also strong evidence that she was pregnant with Hamlet’s child, which, in this time, would have been considered a grave error to have children out of wedlock. So, in an effort to repent of this sin, she drowns herself, the only instance of willing suicide in this play.

Laertes: He is the son of Polonius and brother of Ophelia. Laertes can be very protective of his sister, especially when it comes to dealing with Hamlet. Both he and his father warn Ophelia of getting tangled up with Hamlet; his relationship with Hamlet is in generally hostile, especially near the end of the play where both are heated with emotion. He is also a charmer of the people, as we seem him leading a rabble of commoners that want him to be king near the end of the play.

MOTIFS
  • Ambiguity
  • Insularity

  • Incest
  • Identity
  • Providence
  • Revenge
  • Control
  • Religion
  • Duality (Natural vs. Unnatural, identity vs. public appearance, father & son, light vs. day, pure vs. impure)
  • Death
  • Surveillance
  • Misogyny
  • Ears & hearing
  • Synecdoche
  • Fortune/luck
  • Lack of trust
  • Mystery of death- afterlife
  • Nation as a poisoned body
  • Putting on persons- inner vs. outer self
  • Lies
  • Groups of 3
  • Madness

THEME STATEMENT
Shakespeare’s Hamlet cautions that self doubt paired with moral corruption can lead to the subversion of providence.

QUOTES
"There are more things in heaven and earth, Horatio, that are dreamt of in your philosophy." (Act I, Scene V)
This quote exemplifies the religious and philosophical angst that Hamlet undergoes throughout the play. Even at the end, when he gives himself up to Providence, we, as readers, can still return to quotes like these and "Nothing is either good nor bad but thinking makes it so" and continue to think about the questions Hamlet poses and does not answer.

"Not a whit, we defy augury: there's a special providence in the fall of a sparrow. If it be now, 'tis not to come; if it be not to come, it will be now; if it be not now, yet it will come: the  readiness is all,"  (Act V, Scene II)
This is obviously one of the most important quotes in all the play, for it is the moment where Hamlet fully gives himself over to Providence's command. It is the moment where all his postulating, his questioning, his reasoning is finally resolved within himself, not necessarily with answers, but with a certainty of faith. He is no longer Hamlet 2.0, simply a carbon-copy of his father, but a child of God, given up to his command. The central question of the play, being "will Hamlet relinquish control of himself and his situation", is answered, and he can die with ease.

Sunday, January 19, 2014

Response to Course Material #5 (And #4)

Well, I am officially a lazy arse. Because of my total apathy towards all things in existence and the angsty, existential questions that are constantly swirling around in my head, I did not do the last post of this type, due quite a while ago. So, in a lame effort to make up for that, I'm going to include, in brief, my thoughts on the many versions of Hamlet that we viewed before the break. That's more for my sake than anyone else's, though; I'll begin with our final discussions of the play.

After many wondrous days of delay, we finally got around to finalizing our views on Hamlet, and I can tell you, a early-three-week break does not do good things for a discussion on such a complicated play. Every time we began discussing, it took a little time for us to get into it, but we eventually got some good work done. Initially, our hour engaged the concept of the play's turning point and where it might be, along with working out the play's central question. Most all of us agreed that control was such an overarching construct in this play that it had to be included in the question, and our question ended up being "Will Hamlet relinquish control of himself?" In the end, he does, and this is where the debate of the play's turning point began: when exactly does Hamlet relinquish control? Two schools of thought emerged on the subject, one pointing towards the "Poor Yorick" scene, the other to the scene where Hamlet speaks with Horatio before the duel. I believe our class settled pretty evenly on the "Poor Yorick" scene, wherein Hamlet comes to terms that his father was not much of a father figure. This frees Hamlet from his filial obligation and allows him to give control to God, which happens in his conversation with Horatio. We then moved on to the theme statement, which I would usually equate to pulling one's teeth out with needle-nose pliers, but this time around, things went surprisingly smooth. There was little dissent towards the final product (the text of which I cannot remember), and it seems that all that's left is to write the post and wade through the extremely long list of motifs that we also compiled.

Now onto ancient history. Long before the fabled winter break of 2013-2014, our classes viewed many snippets of differing interpretations of Hamlet (among other things), and there was much rejoicing. What I found interesting about this viewing process was the extremes that directors and actors take when interpreting such a famous work. Take, for instance, Derek Jacobi's version of Hamlet. In my opinion, his performance as the titular character sometimes bordered on childishness. The way he thrashed about after his meeting with the ghost almost made me laugh. But then came Lawrence Olivier's reading of Hamlet, which lies in a completely different realm. Olivier kept the character sharp and thoughtful; his emotions rarely boiled over to the same point as Jacobi's. Overall, I thought Olivier displayed a more realistic range of emotion in respect to how I read the character of Hamlet, and I viewed him more as a calculated thinker than a mad hatter. Every interpretation that we explored during this time, including the African tribe's reading and the version given by prisoners, rose a question that has long troubled artists and thinkers: who should we trust? Whose word is the final word? Is there even a final word? And if there isn't, what does that mean for a work? This class has emphasized the idea that differing interpretations are the backbone of literary thought and criticism, and I understand this, but still, what's going on? There are many thousands of people who have taken their stab at interpreting Hamlet, though essays and films and stage productions, but this leaves us with a whirlwind of thoughts and ideas that can be extremely confusing to sort through. I'm still not sure how to work with the essay we read outlining the various theories and schools of thought behind Hamlet; that, in and of itself, was a confusing, messy blob of ideas. If one essay fails to effectively explain and work through Hamlet, then what of the other thousands trying to do the same thing? They so often contradict and refute each other, trying to gain a higher position on the hierarchical ladder of literary thought, and many are left by the wayside to rot. I've often wavered between objectivity and subjectivity in literature, and Hamlet only worked to confuse my thoughts more (not necessarily in a bad way, for it's always good to think). I doubt that I'll reach a resolution any time soon; and I'd like to hear any opinions anyone has on the matter.

Another point that was made during these past weeks was made by my father, who I was discussing these various films with. We were talking about Kenneth Branagh's version, which he had given five stars in his own film rating system (my father is an avid lover of film, and I often ridicule his picky, sometimes venomous rating system; he rarely gives ratings over one-half star). I had my own issues with Branagh's version, namely the extroverted, grandiose nature of the whole thing, and the silly ending with the big fight scene and Fortinbras's masculine, powerful entrance. He refuted these points though, and said that he gave the film five stars because every single line is included, and that despite the directorial and acting flaws that may be present, the words of Shakespeare reign supreme overall. One can still become familiar with some of the greatest literature ever written in the English language, despite the medium of film and its flaws. This idea can be applied to the story we listened to about Hamlet being performed by prisoners. The obvious flaw there is that those prisoners were not professional, trained actors; they were just people, yet they still managed to convey the messages of Shakespeare. They connected immensely with the characters and words that were written hundreds of years ago, putting their own emotions into text that has been read before the highest of the high. My father convinced me to let off a bit on Branagh's version, flawed as it may be, because I still have one of the greatest works of all time to listen to while watching Robin Williams appear quite arbitrarily and Hamlet swing down from a giant chandelier. It may not have redeemed the film as a whole for me, but it made me appreciate the words of Shakespeare all the more.

Sunday, January 12, 2014

Response to Prompt #1

Prompt: 2004 Form A - "Critic Roland Barthes has said 'Literature is the question minus the answer.' Choose a novel, or play, and considering Barthes' observation, write an essay in which you analyses a central question the work raises and the extent to which it offers answers. Explain how the author's treatment of this question affects your understanding of the work as a whole. Avoid mere plot summary."

As humans advanced into the modern age during the industrial revolution, optimists and dreamers began conjuring up images of success that have stuck with us to this day. These images revolve around hard work, dedication, and coming from the bottom and making it big: the prototypical American dream. In Arthur Miller's Death of a Salesman, the question of "what is the answer to becoming successful" is posed, often by Willie Loman, the play's main character, a question he has been searching for the answer to all his life.

The character of Willie Loman is one who has been consistently deluded by the ideals of "rags-to-riches" stories that have followed him throughout his life, though Willie has never been able to achive this kind of success. Willie's deceased brother Ben was a successful diamond miner who immigrated to Africa when he was 18 and made his fortune by age 21, at least according to Willie's memory. Before leaving, Ben had asked him to go with him (initially to Alaska to find their gold-mining father), but Willie decided not to. Willie had met an old salesman, one who had obtained success at his old age and was known by clients far and wide; he did not even have to leave his home to make a sale. Spurred by these successful images, Willie began searching for the kind of success Ben had through the masque of the old salesman. But, this kind of success was never achieved, and Willie eventually convinced himself that even though he was just another hard-working, penny-ante salesman, he was well-known, well-liked and successful. In the back of his mind, though, he knew that he was not like Ben and the old salesman. This repressed knowledge drives Willie's search for "the answer" to success, often asking the memory of Ben what it is; Ben never gives a straight answer, and neither do any of the other characters that he asks.

The lack of a clear answer to this question drives the themes and meanings found in this play. We discover through memories that Willie loves carpentry. He tells tales of when he built both the roof and the front porch to his house, and these parts of memories are often when we see him the happiest. Willie's son, Biff, also has been warped by the "rags-to-riches" perception of success. Biff was lauded as a child for his athletic ability, but was disillusioned when he discovered an affair his father was having. Since then, Biff has wandered from job to job, city to city, looking for work and himself, while his father desires that he become a salesman as well. Biff's true desires lie in manual labor and outdoor farm work, though he denies these feelings because of his father's influence. In his search for success, Biff practices self-sabotage whenever things are going well on a farm and returns to New York to get a "real" job, one he does not want. The characters of Biff and Willie are both looking for the same thing, success, but their perceptions of success have been warped by the influence of others, and by the society that endorses these ideas. They go through life asking, out-loud and tacitly, "what's the answer?", when it lies in front of them the entire time. Miller does not provide an explicit answer, and, in a sense, that is the answer, that there isn't one. A person must discover his own answer and follow his own desires to become "successful", not conform to a predisposed notion of success. The failure to discover this by Willie eventually leads to his suicide, though Biff vows to follow through on his dreams and become what he may. The course of action Willie took lead to incredibly harmful consequences, mainly the emotionally damaged state that every one of his family members is in. This is the warning that Miller gives us, that the denial of true desires will lead to drastic, sometimes irreversible consequences.

As a modernist, questions about success and the validity of the American dream were hot on the minds of writers like Miller during the forties and fifties, and Death of a Salesman is a prime example of these questions. Miller does not go about finding the answer to success, but throws out the notion of a single answer, showing us how destructive and corrosive the search can be. It is no wonder that Miller was seen as a danger to the United States during these years in writing; a challenge to the status quo this big rivals another work along this same path, The Crucible, which decried the anti-Communist trials of Joe McCarthy. But he was merely following his own warnings, doing what he desired most in writing these controversial plays instead of giving his ideals up for safety.