Sunday, October 27, 2013

Responses to Course Material #2

Woo hoo! We're off on yet another adventure in AP Lit down the "Scrutiny-of-American-Society-and-Culture" Road! I am speaking, of course, of Death of a Salesman, which, in between discussions of poetry and how to answer multiple choice questions, is the main focus of our energy this time around. I can see why Salesman and The American Dream are read in direct succession, as they deal with very similar topics; and I'm loving the discussions we're having. Like Albee, Miller delves into the American Dream and how it has corrupted those who choose to follow it so dearly; and as we see Willy Loman wander strangely through visions and reality throughout Death of a Salesman, we are reminded of the contradictory and confused characters Albee presented to us only a month ago. On Friday, we were presented with several points of view on whether Salesman is a true tragedy, as it is often called, and after some thinking I have to say that, in a Shakespearean sense, it does not function as one. There are no noble characters, very little talk of revenge, and no unrealistic bloodbath at the end (though Willy does kill himself), and I don't think Miller intended for this play to be a traditional tragedy, as he highlighted in his essay on tragedy. He writes that tragedy is not exclusively reserved for nobility, and that commoners like Willy can be tragic as well, and I think he accomplishes this goal. I'm sure there'll be a big hullabaloo about this during discussions tomorrow, and I'd like to see how this viewpoint is challenged.

Otherwise, we've been doing some lovely little discussions about poetry, really digging into the meanings that so few words convey. It seems like such a long time ago when we first read "My Father's Song" by Simon Ortiz; and it's amazing how much we pulled out of it. All of the images, the diction and language Ortiz uses, the circularity with the first and last lines, all of it seemed so mundane and normal the first time I read it. I'd read poetry before, but I'd never read into it, which is kind of disappointing to me, because I realize now how much I've missed in past readings of poetry. I could already feel my poetry skills sharpening when next we read "Promises Like Pie-Crust", which had just as many layers of meaning to it, revolving around metaphors of chains and old English proverbs. I'm really enjoying going deeper into poetry, because a good poet can accomplish so much with so little, and that is fascinating.

Our continued practice with AP Exam material is going swimmingly as well, I think. I was rather surprised at how well Simon Tessemer and I did answering the questions on the excerpt from Troilus and Cressida, considering how dense Shakespeare is. I doubt the questions on the actual AP test will be as easy as the ones presented in that old practice test, as the tests shift from year to year, and we could be slammed with some of the most difficult questions that have ever been written. This is of course why Ms. Holmes goes over techniques such as reading the passage, then the stems, then going back in for a closer look. As much as I'd rather be discussing books 'n' such in AP Lit, this is, after all, a class preparing us for the all-important exam in May, so I guess we'd better include some work on how that exam is written and how it functions. I'm more worried about the essays anyway, though we did get some good work done on how to write a closed prompt with "Promises Like Pie-Crust", which is very similar to an open prompt in that everything relates back to meaning, but closed prompts are far more localized as they're about provided excerpts. This is a great boon to anyone taking the exam, as he or she does not have to wrack his brain about some specific image or symbol that he or she can't remember; instead it's right in front of him. 

4 comments:

  1. Great job covering the material and reflecting on its significance to you--I would like to see a bit more synthesis of material across the course and connecting of the material to experiences (academic and otherwise) from outside of this course. Oh, and you might be relieved to learn that most years my students report that the AP multiple choice section is no more difficult (and sometimes easier) than the practice we do in class!

    ReplyDelete
  2. Drew,

    Like Ms. Holmes mentioned you did a great job of covering everything we have done and read recently in class. It is sometimes hard to remember everything we do but you seemed to get everything! Impressive! I can totally to relate to you with regard to thinking about how much I have missed when I have read poetry before this class. It is crazy to think about how much we have learned in such a small amount of time! Like you, I am also worried about the essays on the AP test as well. This is a great response to the material and you also wrote in a way that wasn't boring to read...so thanks:) What has been your favorite part of the class so far?

    ReplyDelete
  3. Drew,
    The great thing about your posts is that they sound just like you and I can totally see you saying these things in person. This was a great analysis of what we have done so far in class and covered all the bases. I wish you had talked more about things in our class discussions that have caught your attention or that you hadn’t thought about before, just to see how they are affecting you and your thinking of the plays. The parts were you talked about the practice multiple choice and poetry reading that we are doing was great. I agree with you that I have never really read into poetry before, at least not like this, and I too feel my poetry skills sharpening. Unlike you and Simon, I still struggle with Shakespeare and his denseness, and so struggle with the questions. My problem seems to be that I take something different from the poems than what may be expected and so often what I read and interpret do not match the correct answers of the questions. Do you ever have this problem? Once again great post Drew.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Drew,
    How excellently you covered the material discussed thus far in class. I don't think you forgot to mention anything, and you did a good job of vocalizing your thoughts on the various things that we did in class rather than just reiterating what we already know. I have a problem with doing this within my own posts. A bit more commentary as to what your class discussed specifically regarding the plays and poems we read would be appreciated though. As a member of 6th hour (The greatest hour), it would be helpful to be able to see what your class does differently than ours. In general though this is a very well done analysis!
    P.S. Please continue to use the word "swimmingly" in as many of your blogs as possible. Thank you.

    ReplyDelete