2003 Question 3
LL'LL: There is very little to criticize in this student's essay analysing tragic heroes in The Great Gatsby. There was virtually no plot summary; the only summary apparent was necessary to elaborate on the point being made. The author made his or her points extremely clear to the reader, and overall the analysis was accurate, well-organised and even enjoyable to read, which is hard to say for most AP essays. This student delved into all aspects of the character of Jay Gatsby, and makes the case for him being tragic in a pitiful, almost inevitable way, while also making the connection that Gatsby represents the whole of the Jazz Age and its failures and faults. I would wholeheartedly award this essay a nine, for it represents all the necessary traits a good AP essay should have. I will most definitely use this as a template for my own essays once I begin writing more of them.
C: This student did not do as good a job as the former student did with this prompt, though this essay is not without its merits. The author seemed unable to really articulate what he or she wanted to say about King Lear, and it was confusing while reading the essay where the plot summaries included wanted to go. In the end, the student does a nice job summing up her points about duty and how the lack of duty and the presence of greed and Lear's ego all lent to his place as a tragic figure, though these points were far less clear in the body text. Overall, I would give this student a six, for the knowledge is present, though its exercise was not as precise and direct as it could have been.
FF,: I find that this essay on One Flew Over The Cuckoo's Nest somewhat misses the intent of the prompt. Rather than examining the tragedy of one character, which would be the newest patient McMurphy, the author instead anaylses how the tragedy of McMurphy causes suffering for others. He or she merely writes off the tragedy of McMurphy as "the utmost tragedy", but fails to explain in any great depth why that is. Instead, the author goes on a lengthy plot summary of one of the final scenes, where a character commits suicide and McMurphy is sent off to electroshock therapy. In essence, this plot summary makes no final point in relation to the intent of the prompt, instead talking about the tragedy of other characters. I would give this essayist a lower score than a four, but I feel I must keep it at that level, for the author is fairly competent, I just believe that the plot summary takes up too much space and the final points about tragic heroes are never reached.
Drew,
ReplyDeleteI think you did a good job at summarizing theses essays, but I think you should also take more time in explaining what you thought of them. I noticed that you didn’t use any quotes, which is a shame, because I would really like to know what specific point made you want to use the essay as a structure to your own. In the second paragraph you say “This student did not do as good a job as the former student did with this prompt, though this essay is not without its merits” but then you don’t really say specifically gave the essay those merits. Besides that, there are a few questions that should probably be answered in your post. Why you would give them a certain score, or why you disagree with the scores that they got. I know that you did cover a few of these in one or more of your essay analysis paragraphs, but its important that they all have each question answered. I think you are on the right track, but there are a few points that really need clarification, I think that if you just address them, that you would have a much better post.
Drew,
ReplyDeleteI have to agree with Rachel that I thought you did a pretty nice job on analyzing these student essays but I feel like you could have done it a little more explaining. I also noticed that you did not include any quotes and I think that is pretty important since we haven't read the essays. If you just added quotes then we could be sure that all the great thoughts you have are accurate. I really liked how in your first paragraph you said, "i will most definitely use this as a template for my own essays." No essays are perfect, so I think it is important to remember that our essay does not have to be perfect to receive a good score. Overall, I thought you did a fine job with this blog post but I think you definitely could have explained yourself a little more!
Drew great job analyzing and describing these student essays. It seems that these prompts provided you with the best, being an essay that directly answers the prompt and another that just simply summarizes. The first essay you even say could become an essay that you later reference when nearing closer to the AP exam, that must've been a pretty good essay and I will definitely look into it! It seems the student included all of the essential traits that an AP grader is looking for. In contrast, the last essay seemed to be the worst; it simply just summarized the novel and failed to fully develop and explain the main points that were necessary. This seems to be a common mistake for students when writing during the AP exam and Ms. Holmes has even warned us several of times to be conscious of this fatal mistake. This was a good analysis overall, although I do agree with Rachel there are a few things that you could further expand on that would improve this post but overall it very good, great job!
ReplyDelete