Summary
Death of a Salesman begins with Willy Loman
returning from a long sales trip, exhausted. His wife, Linda, greets him as he
arrives, and pressures him to talk to his boss and get a job in the city.
Upstairs, their two sons, Biff and Happy, lie awake reminiscing about the days
of youth. They discuss their father’s hallucinations, which occur more
frequently whenever Biff comes back to town. The reader experiences one of
these flashbacks first-hand while Willy wanders around the outside of his
house. Happy, concerned, goes downstairs to try and coax his father to go to bed.
Eventually, Willy’s visions grow too intense and he begins shouting. Biff comes
downstairs asking about his father, and Linda confronts him about his decisions
and the disrespect directed towards Willy. To calm his father down, Happy presents an idea to Biff to sell sporting goods, and Willy suggests he take it to Bill Oliver, one of Biff's old employers who Willy is sure will remember him. The next
day, Biff leaves the house early to meet with Oliver while Willy goes to New
York to talk to Howard Wagner, the boss of his firm, about a city job. A dinner
between the father and his sons is arranged after. Willy arrives in Howard’s
office, but after Howard rejects his proposal, saying that there is no room for
him. Willy is distraught and begins to shout at Howard about “promises” made to
him earlier in his career. Willy is promptly fired; and he wanders out of
the building talking to himself, going to Charley’s workplace to ask him for
money. When he’s there, he meets Bernard, Charley’s son and a childhood friend
of Biff’s, who is now a successful lawyer. Willy asks Bernard what the answer
to success is and why Biff never achieved it, but Bernard cannot provide a
concrete answer. Meanwhile, Happy and Biff arrive at the dinner, and Biff tells
Happy of his failure with Bill Oliver. Biff had waited for hours in Oliver’s
office, until he finally stepped out, where Oliver did not recognize him and
barely paid him any mind. Biff plans to tell Willy all of this, but when he
does Willy denies him. Happy eventually leaves with two women and drags Biff
with him, leaving Willy in a hallucinatory state. Here, Willy recalls how Biff
discovered that he had an affair with a secretary in Boston, which is the main
reason for Biff’s distancing from his father and his wanderings through life.
Happy
and Biff return home after leaving their father at the restaurant to find Linda
angry at both of them. Biff, enraged by the constant lies of Happy and his
father, declares that he must tell Willy the truth about himself, despite
Linda’s protestations. Willy continues to ignore Biff's assertions that he is no good, and eventually Biff collapses on him, crying and hugging him. Willy takes this as a sign that Biff has forgiven him, and in a state of elation crashes his car and kills himself to grant Biff twenty thousand dollars in insurance claims that Willy assumes Biff will use to go into business. The play ends with Willy's funeral, and at it Happy declares he willy follow in his father's footsteps; Biff firmly decides to forge his own path.
Analysis
Arthur
Miller’s Death of a Salesman suggests
that society’s superficial idea of success does not always match that of the
individual, and that the denial of one’s true dreams can lead to catastrophic
consequences.
The setting of Death of a Salesman shifts between the Lomans’ home and the city of
New York. At the house, the walls are broken up by spaces to allow characters
to pass between them in Willy’s flashbacks; they cannot do this during the
present. The ability for characters to pass through walls in Willy’s flashbacks
demonstrate his unreliability as a narrator, for no person can simply walk
through walls in reality; as well as being a practical measure. In New York,
Willy travels to the office of Howard Wagner, the head of the firm he works
for, and later to Frank’s Chop House, a restaurant.
Characters of Greatest Import:
Willy Loman: The main protagonist of this
play, Loman is a hard-working salesman whose dream is to achieve “success.” His
father abandoned him and his brother when they were young, going of too Alaska,
which instilled in Willy the desire to make it on his own out in the frontier,
though his mind was eventually changed when he heard tales of a successful,
“well-liked” salesman who was known throughout the land and lived comfortably.
Sucked in by this idea he worked and worked but never achieved this vision.
Willy is extremely prideful and desires control, though he is also wracked by
guilt, not only towards his wife and children, but also towards himself. Willy
experiences many flashbacks to happier times, which frighten the rest of his
family. His memories are often distorted and cannot be taken as fact.
Linda Loman: Willy’s husband, Linda
struggles with Willy and his passionate feelings daily. She loves him despite
Willy’s sometimes cruel treatment of her, even though Willy is unfaithful to
her. Linda does not know how to keep Willy from harming her and himself because
of her love and her belief that he is his own man, and can be seen as an
enabler. Linda’s relationship with her sons has been strained due to their
inattention to Willy, especially with Biff.
Biff Loman: Biff was the former captain of
his high school football team and had dreams of playing professionally, even
playing at Ebbets Field. Willy showered Biff with praise in his youth, building
up his confidence and abilities and largely ignoring his other son. Biff later
lost faith in his father’s praise when he discovered the affair Willy was
having with a secretary. He then wandered through life, forgetting his dreams
and going out west to work as a rancher, though he too feels guilt, especially
for not telling Linda about the affair. Biff is a kleptomaniac who steals
whenever things seem to be going right, as a form of self-sabotage. He rejects
the dreams of being a salesman that Willy planted in him and wants something
more down-to-earth.
Harold “Happy” Loman. Happy is the neglected child of
the Loman family. Due to Willy constantly lauding Biff, Happy was starved for
attention and had to work for his father’s validation. Happy is moderately
“successful”: he has an apartment, a car, and women. Both he and
Happy often treat women as objects and pay them little regard as human beings,
as demonstrated in the restaurant scene and their remembrances of youth. Unlike
Biff, Happy believes in the dreams their father told them about, and at the end
of the play declares that he will follow in his father’s footsteps and go into
business. His name is ironic as he is not really fulfilled or happy in life.
Ben Loman: Willy’s deceased brother, Ben
is Willy’s model for success. At the age of eighteen Ben travelled to Africa
and eventually made a fortune in diamond mining. His relationship with his
brother was never good, visiting him sparingly and never staying long; and none
of Ben’s wealth ever came into Willy’s hands. It is unsure if Ben ever actually
visited the Lomans, as whenever Willy talks to Ben in a flashback the other
characters’ speech reverts to a highly simplified form, as if Willy were making
it up.
Charley and Bernard: Charley is Willy’s closest
friend, and Bernard is his son. Charley is a moderately successful man it would
seem; he’s able to lend money to Willy on a regular basis and heads his own
business. Bernard is a successful lawyer who was a childhood friend of Biff’s.
Willy once did not believe Bernard would be successful because he was not “well
liked”, but in his old age now looks up to him for the “answer” to success.
Major Motifs:
Machines
and Nature: I have thought that the juxtaposition of these opposites, which occurs
mainly in Willy and Biff, represents the conflicts between what the individual
wants and what a society has imposed on him. It also serves as a criticism of
society, represented in machines, which are usually broken and in need of
fixing (the washing machine, refrigerator, Willy’s car, etc.). Both Willy and
Biff desire to “use their muscles”, as it were, and work with “natural” things,
such as Willy building the roof and porch and Biff working as a rancher. Willy
and Biff have had their true dreams repressed over the years, though, not only
by themselves but by outside forces (society to Willy, Willy to Biff). The one
machine that does not seem to malfunction is Howard’s wire recorder, which is
so frightening to Willy because it cannot lie like he can; it perfectly
replicates the past, which is something Willy constantly strives to deny.
Stealing:
There are several instances of stealing in this play, the most notable being
the theft of Bill Oliver’s fountain pen by Biff near the end. Biff’s stealing
was initially encouraged by Willy, as exemplified by the football and the
construction equipment stolen in one of Willy’s flashbacks. Later in life Biff
steals to sabotage himself because he cannot live with the pressure his father
put on him as a child, constantly praising him in order to drive his success.
Biff’s stealing in his youth seemed to have more of a purpose other than
self-sabotage, whether it be to practice football or to help his father with
building a porch. I would assume that Biff neither desires nor needs a golden
fountain pen, or the suits he stole in Kansas City. These thefts point to
another motif, superficiality, which will be discussed later.
Values
of Success and the American Dream: Willy is constantly bombarding his family
with his idea of what success should be, saying that if a man is “well-liked”
he can and will get anywhere he needs to in life. He speaks nothing of actual
hard work, despite knowing hard work all too well, though the work Willy really
revels in and works hard at is not the kind of work presented in these values.
Willy’s successful idol is his brother Ben, who made his fortune mining
diamonds in Africa. The circumstances through which Ben came to gain this
fortune are hazy; and Ben never offers Willy an answer when Willy implores him
for “the secret” to success. When we step back and remove ourselves from Willy’s
confused perception of himself, we see that he is nothing more than a
lower-class, hard-working salesman who never made it anywhere, despite having
an impossible dream to do so. Willy’s dreams to become the salesman who is
well-liked and known all over the country are impossible because they are not
actually his; American society has implanted these values in him through Dave
Singleman, an old, successful salesman whose realization of wealth and comfort
replaced much of Willy’s true desires.
Superficiality:
Willy’s notion of how to achieve success is a purely superficial one: if one is
“well-liked”, and only this, he will make it. He does not take into account a
person’s inner character or any beliefs or dreams that a person may have. Both
the suit and the fountain pen that Biff steals are superficial status symbols
that point to nothing inward. The Loman’s refrigerator was bought on the basis
of advertisement size, assuming that if the ad was bigger, the refrigerator would
be better (this is not the case). Biff and Happy’s treatment of women also
demonstrates supreme superficiality, as Happy treats women as prizes to be had,
not people, and does not care about them as people. All of these
superficialities in the play point to Miller’s distaste for American superficiality,
which was running rampant in 1949, the year he wrote this play.
Selling
of ideas and the self: The question that is often brought up about Willy is “what
does he sell”; and Miller provides no concrete answer. One answer is that Willy
sells the idea of selling itself, not to customers, but to everyone around him.
Biff is told by Willy that he will go into business and be a salesman just like
his father (on the basis of being well-liked). Linda is reassured by her
husband that he is a successful salesman and that selling is a good job, and
Linda believes him, backing him up when Ben questions Willy’s decision to sell.
Dave Singleman, Willy’s inspiration, sold Willy the idea of selling a long time
ago. And in turn, society sells us the idea of selling along with old Dave.
Death: The
main death in this play is obviously the death of Willy, which is foreshadowed
from the opening scene (from the title, too) until he crashes his car at the
end. Not only does Willy die, but many others, such as Ben, Willy’s father, his
old boss who promised him a promotion, and many of Willy’s old clients have
died. The death of his boss and clients show that selling itself is dying, as
well as Howard not being able to fit Willy into an office job, as there are
only six salesmen on the floor. Along with physical death, Willy dies “the
death of a salesman” in the office scene where Howard treats him like a child
and fires him, destroying once and for all the dream that Willy worked so hard
for but never achieved. In the end, Willy kills himself to try and jumpstart
Biff along a “successful” path, as the insurance money earned from the crashing
of the car would be more than enough to get him along. Willy, however, never
realizes who Biff really is, despite Biff up and saying it to his face just
before he kills himself.
Contradictions
and Lies: Every single member of the Loman family is guilty of contradicting
and/or lying to themselves or others. Willy believes he is successful one
minute and then declares himself a failure the next; he refuses to believe that
Biff cannot be a salesman; he can seem so sure of his position and then tell
himself that he isn’t settled yet; the list continues. Happy emulates his father
in that he compulsively lies, often with a straight face, especially in the
restaurant scene where much of the dialogue is built off of Happy’s lies
surrounding Biff’s meeting with Bill Oliver. Linda knows that Willy is not who
he builds himself up to be yet she can’t bring herself to tell him that,
effectively lying to him by supporting this vision. Both Willy and Biff lie to
themselves about their true dreams and desires, pursuing things that they do
not really want. These contradictions and lies bring forth the conflict and
contradictions between what an individual wants and what a society wants for an
individual, which is the cornerstone of Miller’s ideas in this play.
Conflict:
The Loman family seems to be in constant conflict with each other, whether it
be verbal or physical. The most obvious conflict is between Biff and Willy, who
are at odds with each other over Biff’s life decisions. At the same time, these
two characters experience deep internal conflicts over their dreams. Happy competes
with Biff for their father’s attention, whether it is negative attention or
not. Linda is conflicted internally over whether or not to dispose of the
rubber tube that Willy plans to gas himself with, and she does not know how to
confront Willy about the tough issues in his life and still let him remain
himself. Willy has a major conflict with Howard Wagner over his job, which
parallels the conflict between Linda and Willy. Their conflict stems from Willy’s
weariness and his desire for control: he dominates any conversation they have
with each other and often tells Linda to be quiet when she tries to interject. Though
the tone shifts from character to character in this play, the tone of the Loman
family is very similar, and could be described as tense and argumentative. The
Lomans are constantly talking down to each other and have a difficult time
communicating effectively.
Many of these motifs, notably stealing, conflict, contradictions, and death, are direct consequences of the individual's denial of his or her true dreams. Willy's mind, body, and family have all depreciated because of the dreams implanted in him. These are the "catastrophic consequences" spoken of in the theme statement: the loss of one's body, mind, and family.
Quotes:
"But then, it's what I always wanted. My own apartment, a car, and plenty of women. And still, goddammit, I'm lonely!" Happy, p. 23
This quote exemplifies the ideas that Miller criticizes in Death of a Salesman and demonstrates how they do not fulfill any real needs. Happy may have his superficial success of property (this includes women; he treats them terribly) and money, but he really is not happy.
This quote emphasizes one of Miller's main points in the book, that not all people are "leaders of men" and that not everyone can and should go out and attempt to be one. It also brings Willy's conflicts and problems down to the broadest level possible, which is another piece that the play tries to accomplish.
Drew,
ReplyDeleteYou show a thorough understanding of Death of a Salesman in this post. Your analysis of the symbols and motifs are complete and insightful. I found your comments on Biff's stealing interesting. I always thought the stealing was Biff's way of protesting society's shallow conformity, so hearing your interpretation about the symbols being a form of self sabotage was cool, and I see where you are coming from. My only suggestions would be to address the theme statement and the author's perspective more thoroughly, and be a little more concise (especially in the summary). Overall, solid work!
Drew, this is a great summary and conclusion of Death of a Salesman! Although it is a little long, it was very thorough and I really enjoyed reading it. You highlighted on very important things and clearly display that you have a good understanding of Death of a Salesman. While reading this it kept me really thinking and when you were describing Happy it made me wonder, do you think that there is any relationship between Happy's lack of attention from Willy and his level of success compared to Biff? Your descriptions of the symbols were very thought provoking, you brought up some great points that I had not considered before, such as the constant contradicting and lying that happens between the characters. Overall this is a great response and I really enjoyed it, however, my only advice is too add a supportive description about the thesis we decided on in our class. Great work though, this is a great response!
ReplyDelete