Sunday, October 27, 2013

Responses to Course Material #2

Woo hoo! We're off on yet another adventure in AP Lit down the "Scrutiny-of-American-Society-and-Culture" Road! I am speaking, of course, of Death of a Salesman, which, in between discussions of poetry and how to answer multiple choice questions, is the main focus of our energy this time around. I can see why Salesman and The American Dream are read in direct succession, as they deal with very similar topics; and I'm loving the discussions we're having. Like Albee, Miller delves into the American Dream and how it has corrupted those who choose to follow it so dearly; and as we see Willy Loman wander strangely through visions and reality throughout Death of a Salesman, we are reminded of the contradictory and confused characters Albee presented to us only a month ago. On Friday, we were presented with several points of view on whether Salesman is a true tragedy, as it is often called, and after some thinking I have to say that, in a Shakespearean sense, it does not function as one. There are no noble characters, very little talk of revenge, and no unrealistic bloodbath at the end (though Willy does kill himself), and I don't think Miller intended for this play to be a traditional tragedy, as he highlighted in his essay on tragedy. He writes that tragedy is not exclusively reserved for nobility, and that commoners like Willy can be tragic as well, and I think he accomplishes this goal. I'm sure there'll be a big hullabaloo about this during discussions tomorrow, and I'd like to see how this viewpoint is challenged.

Otherwise, we've been doing some lovely little discussions about poetry, really digging into the meanings that so few words convey. It seems like such a long time ago when we first read "My Father's Song" by Simon Ortiz; and it's amazing how much we pulled out of it. All of the images, the diction and language Ortiz uses, the circularity with the first and last lines, all of it seemed so mundane and normal the first time I read it. I'd read poetry before, but I'd never read into it, which is kind of disappointing to me, because I realize now how much I've missed in past readings of poetry. I could already feel my poetry skills sharpening when next we read "Promises Like Pie-Crust", which had just as many layers of meaning to it, revolving around metaphors of chains and old English proverbs. I'm really enjoying going deeper into poetry, because a good poet can accomplish so much with so little, and that is fascinating.

Our continued practice with AP Exam material is going swimmingly as well, I think. I was rather surprised at how well Simon Tessemer and I did answering the questions on the excerpt from Troilus and Cressida, considering how dense Shakespeare is. I doubt the questions on the actual AP test will be as easy as the ones presented in that old practice test, as the tests shift from year to year, and we could be slammed with some of the most difficult questions that have ever been written. This is of course why Ms. Holmes goes over techniques such as reading the passage, then the stems, then going back in for a closer look. As much as I'd rather be discussing books 'n' such in AP Lit, this is, after all, a class preparing us for the all-important exam in May, so I guess we'd better include some work on how that exam is written and how it functions. I'm more worried about the essays anyway, though we did get some good work done on how to write a closed prompt with "Promises Like Pie-Crust", which is very similar to an open prompt in that everything relates back to meaning, but closed prompts are far more localized as they're about provided excerpts. This is a great boon to anyone taking the exam, as he or she does not have to wrack his brain about some specific image or symbol that he or she can't remember; instead it's right in front of him. 

Sunday, October 20, 2013

Open Prompts #2

2004 Question 3

Response "N": I was rather impressed with this student's response to the prompt, where he or she used Candide to answer the prompt, which deals with questions raised in literature and how authors answer them. Though the student did tend to summarize quite a bit in the first paragraph, all of the summarizing was relevant to his or her analysis. The student goes into great detail to explain how the central question in Candide, "Is this the best of all possible worlds", is answered and how it relates to the book's meaning. The author tells us of Candide's exploits throughout the book and how he is always unsatisfied with the worlds he encounters, which leads him to the conclusion that "we must tend our garden" when it comes to the world, meaning we all must do what is necessary to keep this world better. The student mainly examines details from the plot, such as Candide's expulsion from his castle, his time spent in war, and his journey to the mythic El Dorado, though she does not do this simply to summarize. With each point the author ties it back to the central question, saying, in the case of El Dorado, that Candide could not reconcile his already-embedded sense of greed and lust in a society where greed and lust did not exist. Though the student does not directly state it, he or she does tie the question and his or her points back to the meaning of the book in the third paragraph, using Candide's answer to the central question to back up the book's point that "we all must strive to make each individual life the best possible." Overall, I would give this student a solid 8, for though he or she did a wonderful job responding to the prompt, there was enough summarizing present to knock it back a point.

Response "J": Compared to the first response, this takes quite a dive in quality of evidence. This essay is about Huckleberry Finn and the question "what does it mean to be free", and the author sets us up for something great, with the opportunity for many specific details, though he or she does not deliver to the fullest extent. The first paragraph is essentially plot summary, with the author telling us how Jim and Huck are both enslaved in different ways and escape on a raft to escape that slavery, but he or she does not attempt to connect with the central question or meaning in any way. In the following paragraphs many attempts to relate details and images from the text to the question are made, but they are all to vague to be concrete. Take the author's point that "When in town or with the 'King' or 'Duke', Huck and Jim must hide their feelings for each other because of society's conventions about race", which addresses an important issue in the book, but doesn't relate the point made back to the question in full. One can discern a skeleton of what this essayist is saying, but it is in no way fleshed out enough to be given a high score. I think a 5 would be an appropriate score for this student.

Response "uu": The sparsity of this essay was an immediate tip-off to the fact that I wasn't going to be reading something very deep; you can't fit much into one-and-a-half pages of AP writing space, unless you're a fantastic writer who's mastered concise diction at the age of seventeen. The essay attempts to analyse the book Things Fall Apart and the question "does anything ever stay the same." The author introduces the main character Okonkwo, who stubbornly resists change in his village. There are no specific points of evidence brought up about Okonkwo or his village (other than he's stubborn); the author merely insists that "as time passed, changes began to form" in this village. These changes were apparently caused by "cultural persuasions", though no examples are given. The author attempts to relate back to the question in saying "Achebe's use of cultural changes and development makes the work apprehendable to realize that things do change and never stay the same", but the fact that no examples of cultural persuasions were presented in the essay make this statement irrelevant. Not only this, the author twists "apprehend" into a different form that makes no sense in the context of the sentence. Vague, incorrect diction and simplistic writing such as this appears all throughout the essay, as in "The village of the story during the time period has its difference and consists of contrasting views, opinions and characteristics about life", which make the piece as a whole difficult to read. Due to these errors, I would have to give this essayist a 3 for the work.

Tuesday, October 15, 2013

Summary and Analysis of "The American Dream"

Summary
Edward Albee's The American Dream begins rather unsuspectingly, with Mommy and Daddy sitting in their living room, idly waiting for a repairman to come to their apartment. They jabber for a while, complaining about the toilet not being fixed and Mommy's dispute over the color of her new hat, until Grandma appears from the rooms behind, carrying a large amount of wrapped boxes. Grandma, old, creaky, and omniscient in the scope of the play, dismisses Mommy and Daddy's criticisms of old age and goes about her business gathering up boxes. A little while later, the characters hear a knock on the door, and who should arrive but Mrs. Barker, the chairman of Mommy's woman's club. Strangely enough, none of the characters, including Mrs. Barker herself, know why she's here. Mommy and Daddy ask if she is the "van man", there to take Grandma off to a nursing home to symbolically die, but Mrs. Barker knows she is not here for that. Soon enough, Mrs. Barker takes a liking to Grandma, and while Mommy and Daddy are sent offstage to look for a glass of water, Grandma reveals that Mrs. Barker took place in the adoption of Mommy and Daddy's "bumble", who Mommy mutilated to perfection. Mommy then calls Mrs. Barker into the kitchen for her glass of water, and in her absence a young man knocks on the door and is let in. Grandma is drawn to his chiseled body and "typically American" looks, and declares him to be the American Dream. And with this young Dream's appearance, Grandma sees her way out of the personal hell that is the apartment: she quietly slips out the door, boxes in tow, and stands at the front of the stage. Mommy and Daddy reenter the living room and Mommy is instantly seduced by the young man, leaving Daddy rather uncomfortable. The curtain falls on the sight of Mommy sidling up to the young man; and with the curtain down Grandma closes off the play, leaving us where "everybody's got what he wants... or everybody's got what he thinks he wants."

Analysis
Edward Albee warns us in "The American Dream" that the current generation of Americans has gutted original American values from society and replaced them with a materialistic longing for unattainable satisfaction; but there is still hope for a change for the better.

How do these motifs relate to the theme?

- Emasculation of male roles (Daddy, psychologically damaged husband, wheelchair-bound husband, sexually incapable young man): Albee seems to be saying that, in the desire for "satisfaction", what makes a man a man, whether it be his penis or his independence, is lost in that desire, namely, the drive for a woman. This "new" dream includes the myth of the stable American family: wife, husband, 2.5 children, etc., and includes the assumed stipulation that men must be tied to women, like Daddy is tied to Mommy. In essence men have tricked themselves into wanting something they don't necessarily need, and in the process have had their tubes replaced with tracts and can no longer make decisions. They aren't satisfied because what they want is different from what they think they want. This could also be blown up into a synthesis of Albee's point as a whole, that we all have tricked ourselves into wanting things we don't need, and have therefore gutted what makes us ourselves. However, Grandma, who possesses an androgynous, somewhat masculine nature, points to a time in America when men did have more power, when they were in some ways equal to women but in many ways above them.

- Domineering female characters (Mommy, Mrs. Barker):
Pretty much every feminine role in this play domineers over a male role. Even in the opening scene, when
Mommy explains her predicament with her hat, she repeatedly asks Daddy if he's listening to her, and Daddy wearily replies that he is, despite having drifted off into a daydream. Later, Mommy reproaches Daddy for
insulting Grandma, despite the fact that Grandma is routinely insulted and examined by Mommy. Mommy also has no sensitivity for her husband, blatantly stating to Mrs. Barker that he has undergone some sort of surgery (a sex change); and she often bashes him for being indecisive. Albee has removed the nurturing, mothering instinct from women in this play, which is directly related to the gutting of original, more potent values from American society. In the desire for money and status and "satisfaction", women have taken a state of savagery and control over men. It's as if he desires what came before in the old values (embodied in Grandma), where women stood below the status of men, which strongly points to this play not being pro-feminist.

- Lack of empathy in characters:
The main examples of this motif would be Mrs. Barker's false empathy for Daddy's operation and later, her
inability to feel remorse for the mutilated child of Mommy and Daddy. Here Albee is saying that the fake values of satisfaction, money, consumerism, etc., have replaced the humanistic tendencies in people. Instead of Mrs. Barker lamenting the death of a child she laments the loss of capital, the loss of money in the investment that was the child. She focuses not on the humanity of the person but a person's value, measured in money.

- Lack of "real" values; emotionally void characters:
What this new dream has done to these characters is created self-centered motivation. In a person's desire for "satisfaction", they yearn for personal satisfaction. The Young Man is not seen as a person but as an object to be used for others' sexual gratification, Daddy is simply a way for Mommy to get rich without trying, and Grandma too is even swept into this with her Day-Old Cake scam in the baking contest. The desire for satisfaction has replaced what is real and meaningful in the world, which is why Mommy mutilated her adopted child and why his twin no longer can feel distinct emotions.

- Childlike behavior
All characters, excepting Grandma and the Young Man, are all extremely childlike in their ways of speaking and acting. Their diction is simplistic, they fight over petty differences, and their opinions change very quickly. To Albee, the loss of maturity in adults is a result of childlike conformism to the ideals of this new dream. People no longer consider what personal satisfaction may be, only what society determines it to be, and follow it blindly.

- Repressed sexuality and strange sexual imagery
All the sexuality in this play is presented in a childlike, perverse light. Mommy and Daddy cannot speak in normal terms about each other's sexuality or genitalia, instead veiling their meanings in prudish speech; and the Young Man's raw, chiseled body is so much of a draw for Mommy that she desires him despite being her relative (through adoption of his brother). Love is not mentioned at all in the play. Albee is criticizing this kind of sexuality, saying that this new dream has gutted actual human sexual behavior and love from people. And as it is people's insistent desire to conform, nearly everyone has reverted to this kind of sexuality, and in turn deformed themselves as people. "We live in the age of deformity," says Grandma, and this is exactly the kind of conformity Albee is speaking of.

There is strong evidence to show that Albee believes the values of the new American dream can eventually be transcended. Mommy and Daddy's home is an apartment, not a house; inhabitants
cycle in and out of apartments, staying for varying lengths of time. Like Grandma, who represents older values, the values embodied in the Young Man will grow old and eventually depart, making room for something different to take their place.

Albee, Edward. The American Dream, The Sandbox, The Death of Bessie Smith, Fam and Yam. New York City: Dramatists Play Service, Inc., 2009. Print.

Sunday, October 13, 2013

Recycle Your Dreams!

"Recycle Your Dreams" by Susan Koefod
http://www.mcsweeneys.net/articles/recycle-your-dreams

I have to say, reading through articles on McSweeny's is quite a rewarding experience. The satire found on that site is top-notch, and I'm going to relish returning there many a time this year. While trolling through the article titles looking for something interesting, I stumbled on the intriguing "Recycle Your Dreams", by Susan Koefod. She criticizes the malaise that might descend on a hopeful thirty-something who had big ambitions but never followed through on them with a solution: get rid of those dreams with a recycling service, where they'll be reprocessed for someone else. Koefod achieves success in her satire through the use of diction, details and syntax throughout the article.

Here, diction's primary function is to bring attention to the pitiful, unoriginal people that default on their hopes
and dreams and must therefore use this service, and it is quite severe. Koefod always speaks of the dreams
themselves (and in turn the people who possess them) in a highly negative light, describing them as "useless",
"futile" and "toxic", all of which are words stretched to their extremes. All of the unrealized dreams have made "stinking mess[es]" out of these folks's lives; and once those dreams are recycled they are re-implanted in "idiots" who harbor "wilder expectations" than their previous owners. Koefod's condemnation of these lazy idealists is pretty clear through her scathing word choice.

The details in this piece create the false agencies and functions that allow all of this satire to take place, as well as accentuate the criticisms being made. Firstly, Koefod creates a new government agency called the Department of Dashed Hopes that has just instated the Reduce, Reuse, Recycle Your Dreams Program, which reprocesses unfulfilled dreams. The fact that dreams, a highly personal possession, are now treated like reusable garbage effectively detaches them from people, turning them into objects that can be broken and thrown away. Secondly, an offshoot of that agency, the Dream Liberation Army, is run by "Gen-Xers" and "Millennials" who went for liberal arts degrees and are now woefully lost in the world, exactly the kind of people Koefod is targeting. And lastly, Koefod writes that dreams can be composted: simply push them down deep enough into your psyche and they'll soon turn into psychological mulch, which again removes personal value from dreams and treats them like filth (literal filth). Also, the dreams themselves are highly superficial and objective, such as the desire to "make a difference", though what the dreamer really wants is a "cool million."

Stylistically, Koefod's syntax is very similar to that of a government pamphlet or advertisement, which helps to reinforce her sharp-edged tone. The article is divided into sections of short paragraphs, some of these being only a few words long, and it's those sections with the fewest words that carry the most baggage. The first instance of this, a "Here's how" to set up the explanation of the recycling program, gives a reassuring mood to the beginning of the piece. It's as if the program is telling us "You've screwed up, but here's a simple way to make your failures go away." The next little dividing blurb functions the same: "The DHH is here for you in that regard." The program seems to speak to us, as if it were a human, with these little tidbits that ease our mind and take our thoughts away from our missteps. Except it doesn't do that. Soon, the mood shifts to accusatory, the blurbs becoming shorter and sharper. "Did they listen? Oh no" could easily be joined into one, yet the two parts are separate, increasing the accusatory nature of the phrase. Whenever sentences of longer length are employed, they are often highly critical, such as "Making compost keeps these [dreams] out of your daily life, where they do nothing but maintain your illusions that you still might someday be a member of the middle class." Ouch.

Susan Koefod has proved to be a wonderful writer to read, and perhaps she'll publish more in McSweeny's in the future. Her style of degrading diction, sardonic syntax and demeaning details functions extremely well in a satirical context, and I'm sure many of the other articles on McSweeny's employ similar devices.