"Recycle Your Dreams" by Susan Koefod
http://www.mcsweeneys.net/articles/recycle-your-dreams
I have to say, reading through articles on McSweeny's is quite a rewarding experience. The satire found on that site is top-notch, and I'm going to relish returning there many a time this year. While trolling through the article titles looking for something interesting, I stumbled on the intriguing "Recycle Your Dreams", by Susan Koefod. She criticizes the malaise that might descend on a hopeful thirty-something who had big ambitions but never followed through on them with a solution: get rid of those dreams with a recycling service, where they'll be reprocessed for someone else. Koefod achieves success in her satire through the use of diction, details and syntax throughout the article.
Here, diction's primary function is to bring attention to the pitiful, unoriginal people that default on their hopes
and dreams and must therefore use this service, and it is quite severe. Koefod always speaks of the dreams
themselves (and in turn the people who possess them) in a highly negative light, describing them as "useless",
"futile" and "toxic", all of which are words stretched to their extremes. All of the unrealized dreams have made "stinking mess[es]" out of these folks's lives; and once those dreams are recycled they are re-implanted in "idiots" who harbor "wilder expectations" than their previous owners. Koefod's condemnation of these lazy idealists is pretty clear through her scathing word choice.
The details in this piece create the false agencies and functions that allow all of this satire to take place, as well as accentuate the criticisms being made. Firstly, Koefod creates a new government agency called the Department of Dashed Hopes that has just instated the Reduce, Reuse, Recycle Your Dreams Program, which reprocesses unfulfilled dreams. The fact that dreams, a highly personal possession, are now treated like reusable garbage effectively detaches them from people, turning them into objects that can be broken and thrown away. Secondly, an offshoot of that agency, the Dream Liberation Army, is run by "Gen-Xers" and "Millennials" who went for liberal arts degrees and are now woefully lost in the world, exactly the kind of people Koefod is targeting. And lastly, Koefod writes that dreams can be composted: simply push them down deep enough into your psyche and they'll soon turn into psychological mulch, which again removes personal value from dreams and treats them like filth (literal filth). Also, the dreams themselves are highly superficial and objective, such as the desire to "make a difference", though what the dreamer really wants is a "cool million."
Stylistically, Koefod's syntax is very similar to that of a government pamphlet or advertisement, which helps to reinforce her sharp-edged tone. The article is divided into sections of short paragraphs, some of these being only a few words long, and it's those sections with the fewest words that carry the most baggage. The first instance of this, a "Here's how" to set up the explanation of the recycling program, gives a reassuring mood to the beginning of the piece. It's as if the program is telling us "You've screwed up, but here's a simple way to make your failures go away." The next little dividing blurb functions the same: "The DHH is here for you in that regard." The program seems to speak to us, as if it were a human, with these little tidbits that ease our mind and take our thoughts away from our missteps. Except it doesn't do that. Soon, the mood shifts to accusatory, the blurbs becoming shorter and sharper. "Did they listen? Oh no" could easily be joined into one, yet the two parts are separate, increasing the accusatory nature of the phrase. Whenever sentences of longer length are employed, they are often highly critical, such as "Making compost keeps these [dreams] out of your daily life, where they do nothing but maintain your illusions that you still might someday be a member of the middle class." Ouch.
Susan Koefod has proved to be a wonderful writer to read, and perhaps she'll publish more in McSweeny's in the future. Her style of degrading diction, sardonic syntax and demeaning details functions extremely well in a satirical context, and I'm sure many of the other articles on McSweeny's employ similar devices.
Drew,
ReplyDeleteI think you did a really nice job analyzing your article and finding the different techniques that the author used. While I did not read the article I can tell that you put a lot of time into looking through the diction, details and syntax used, and then describing how each are used in the article. It seems like a perfect article to pick since the author uses such strong DIDLS that are easy to spot. If there was one thing you could add to your essay to make it even stronger it would to just be adding more quoted evidence from the article so the readers can see more proof of what you're saying. Overall great work with this analysis and keep up the great work!
I read this on McSweeny's, too--I'm glad you enjoy the site! =) This is a sharp analysis of how satire functions, Drew--nice work.
ReplyDeleteDrew,
ReplyDeleteThis was a really good post and analysis. After reading the article I agree with most everything you said. Your analysis of Koefod’s diction was good, I just wish there was more of it; was the diction colloquial or specific? I’m interested to know what you would have said about these parts of diction and how they contributed to the piece. In the details section of your post you listed many good examples of the details used throughout the piece, and while I feel you did a good job highlighting the details, to me it felt that you were just listing them and almost analyzing on a surface level. Besides saying “that [they] allow all of this satire to take place, as well as accentuate the criticisms being made” you don’t really talk about how the details affected the article or how the reader interprets the article. That said I completely agree with what you said about Koefeod’s syntax and thought you hit the nail on the head here; especially the points you made about the mood shift. Overall, great analysis and good post.
Drew,
ReplyDeleteExcellent analysis of an excellent article. I enjoyed the bitter sarcasm of the author's tone which, knowing you, I am sure is exactly what drew you to it. (Haha… Drew)
I appreciate the way you blend your points into your writing rather than robotically pointing them out in the usual 5-paragraph essay with an intro and conclusion style we’re all used to. It’s a difficult task, but you manage it very well.
I’d have to say that of your paragraphs, the one you wrote about syntax was the best. I like how you related the style of the author to that of a government pamphlet. Such connections are valuable for achieving a better understanding of whatever material is being read. Also, for the record, you do very well with supplying enough evidence to support your claims, as I’ve mentioned before in my comments on your other blogs. This skill will surely benefit you well in the future both in class and on the exam.