Sunday, September 29, 2013

Responses to Course Material #1

Since the beginning of AP Lit, the material we have covered and discussed in class has been quite interesting. I clearly remember the first discussions about DIDLS we had in class about the Hemingway, Hawthorne and whoever-the-third-author-was excerpts, as well as the first time I had "close-read" anything (the Metamorphosis excerpt). Those discussions have begun to change the way I read, in that I am now on the active hunt for symbols and images and important diction and the like that all enhances the meaning of whatever I'm reading. I'm no longer just blindly reading the words on the page for the plot or the characters, I'm looking for the gooey center of meaning found in many novels out there. I'm not saying that there was a revelation in my reading where all past notions of how to read were thrown out the door, but that I am starting to see things differently now; and they're much deeper than I ever expected. Going through and annotating The American Dream would've been a very different experience if I hadn't read about close reading, discussed it, and put it to preliminary practice with Metamorphosis. I can start to see things that I never would've seen before, whether it be giant, obtrusive symbols or single words that carry massive meanings. I'm sure that as the year progresses that I'll become better and better at close reading; at least I hope so.

Speaking of The American Dream, our discussions of that have been quite wonderful. Everyone seems to be contributing in some manner; and the flow of ideas we are producing are fantastic in that they often contrast with each other. Disagreements are beautiful things when discussing literature, and we've got plenty of 'em, and they've all help further our discussion of the play, as they're critical in working out any kinks in any idea presented. One of the bigger disagreements (or just arguments) we had as a class was whether or not Albee was presenting feminist or anti-feminist ideas, looking at the characters of Mommy, Grandma and Mrs. Barker and how they related to each other. As a whole, I think we decided he was firmly anti-feminist, after Ms. Holmes informed us of his background as a repressed homosexual living in New York in the '60s, an environment which does not foster feminist sentiment (there was plenty of textual evidence too, Mommy being domineering, competing with Mrs. Barker, unstable in opinion, etc). When we first read the play aloud, I don't think any of us would've expected to dig as deeply as we have; I know I certainly didn't. But now that we've postulated that Mommy, Daddy and Grandma are just a typical family engaged in a bizarre game of house where rooms disappear and children are mutilated, I think we've got to keep going (though the doll house theory may have gone far enough; that was one of our points of contention in discussion). Let's take the allegories to the extreme, shall we? Albee doesn't mind if we do.

I feel that our discussions of the Theatre of the Absurd and existentialism could have been more in-depth, though they were just "introductions." Both of these topics are intriguing to me, especially existentialism, for there are parts of that philosophy that I subscribe to, mainly the belief that we all are able to make our own decisions, regardless of society's constraints (we just have to deal with consequences). I'd like to go more in-depth in both of these topics, but I'm sure that doing so would require me to read many, many books that I have no time to read. On another topic, we discussed how to write an AP essay the other day, and I have to say I'm not as worried as I was before. Having been in two APs before this one, I've written many an essay, and in each class they've been highly stylized. AP Lit essays seem to be a sort of synthesis of the two types of essays I've written before, with all the information of an AP World essay and the literary style of an APUSH essay. I'm not saying that I could write a high-level essay right at this moment, but my experience with AP writing in the past will surely help.

3 comments:

  1. Hello Drew,

    I'll start out with a compliment, since I really can't think of another way to start out: Nice post Drew!
    Although I agree with you that the DIDLS was an interesting experience, can you go in more depth? You may have already explained how AP Lit. "change[d] the way [you] read" but I may have missed it. How did it change? What aspects cause such a radical shift in your mentality? I see your example with "American Dream" and how you were changed, but in what ways?
    I find it interesting that you say that your discussions have large amounts of disagreements, my class is mostly quiet, with a select few speaking most of the time. Did the disagreements help you dive deeper into the play, or was it the overall group analysis? I don't think you specifically say, oh well. What ideas did you have that your group expand upon, or disagreed with?
    I kinda thought that you would be interested in the literary movements and philosophy that we have been recently covering. Although these comments are supposed to be "analytic" I can't help but mention that. The ideas just seem to fit you.
    I don't really agree with your assessment about the AP essays. Yeah, we both went through the same turbulent AP classes, but I feel that the AP Lit. essays will be less, uh, academic. Instead of "do you know history and how it ties to things" I feel that the Lit. essays will challenge our thinking process more.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Drew,
    I really enjoyed reading your response to course materials. I agree with your statement about DIDLS changing the way I read. Honestly, before this class, I had no idea any of this hidden meaning even existed. It was to my best knowledge, that authors just had to come up with a thought provoking stories. However, as you commented, authors such as Hemingway and Fitzgerald have challenged these ideas, as well as our "close readings." One thing I would have loved for you to include in your post was your first impressions. Were you nervous coming in to the class? Did the arrangement of the desks intimidate you? I was certainly curious. I was also intrigued reading about your analysis of the American Dream. Although our class was prompted on the "doll-house" theory, we didn't quite reach the same conclusions as your class seems to have. For example, we never took into consideration the mutilation of the bumbles as a young child popping off a barbies head. Lastly, I can see what you're saying about the essays. However, for me, I do better with a structured essay than I do with an unstructured one. Overall, I enjoyed reading your responses and your thoughts on what we have done so far. Keep up the good work!

    ReplyDelete
  3. Hi Drew,

    I haven't commented too much on your writing specifically in the my other comments, so I'll mention it here. I really enjoy your style of writing in all these blog posts - it's very refined. I can definitely hear your voice - something as you mentioned, I need to work on. Keep it up, especially with the shocking nouns and verbs! I agree with you that DIDLS has changed the way I read literature and find meaning in seemingly random or arbitrary text. I'd like if you gave a few examples of how DIDLS led you to draw meaning in literature that you wouldn't have found before. Yes, I also would've liked to have gone into more depth on the Existentialism and Theater of the Absurd. I always wished Okemos High School provided a Philosophy class. But I also think it's important to have a thorough understanding on the philosophies authors believe in as it highly influences their work. Finally, I also feel much better about the AP Lit essay after writing one in class and reading sample student essays. It seems similar to essays we've all done before. Great post!

    ReplyDelete