2004 Question 3
Response "N": I was rather impressed with this student's response to the prompt, where he or she used Candide to answer the prompt, which deals with questions raised in literature and how authors answer them. Though the student did tend to summarize quite a bit in the first paragraph, all of the summarizing was relevant to his or her analysis. The student goes into great detail to explain how the central question in Candide, "Is this the best of all possible worlds", is answered and how it relates to the book's meaning. The author tells us of Candide's exploits throughout the book and how he is always unsatisfied with the worlds he encounters, which leads him to the conclusion that "we must tend our garden" when it comes to the world, meaning we all must do what is necessary to keep this world better. The student mainly examines details from the plot, such as Candide's expulsion from his castle, his time spent in war, and his journey to the mythic El Dorado, though she does not do this simply to summarize. With each point the author ties it back to the central question, saying, in the case of El Dorado, that Candide could not reconcile his already-embedded sense of greed and lust in a society where greed and lust did not exist. Though the student does not directly state it, he or she does tie the question and his or her points back to the meaning of the book in the third paragraph, using Candide's answer to the central question to back up the book's point that "we all must strive to make each individual life the best possible." Overall, I would give this student a solid 8, for though he or she did a wonderful job responding to the prompt, there was enough summarizing present to knock it back a point.
Response "J": Compared to the first response, this takes quite a dive in quality of evidence. This essay is about Huckleberry Finn and the question "what does it mean to be free", and the author sets us up for something great, with the opportunity for many specific details, though he or she does not deliver to the fullest extent. The first paragraph is essentially plot summary, with the author telling us how Jim and Huck are both enslaved in different ways and escape on a raft to escape that slavery, but he or she does not attempt to connect with the central question or meaning in any way. In the following paragraphs many attempts to relate details and images from the text to the question are made, but they are all to vague to be concrete. Take the author's point that "When in town or with the 'King' or 'Duke', Huck and Jim must hide their feelings for each other because of society's conventions about race", which addresses an important issue in the book, but doesn't relate the point made back to the question in full. One can discern a skeleton of what this essayist is saying, but it is in no way fleshed out enough to be given a high score. I think a 5 would be an appropriate score for this student.
Response "uu": The sparsity of this essay was an immediate tip-off to the fact that I wasn't going to be reading something very deep; you can't fit much into one-and-a-half pages of AP writing space, unless you're a fantastic writer who's mastered concise diction at the age of seventeen. The essay attempts to analyse the book Things Fall Apart and the question "does anything ever stay the same." The author introduces the main character Okonkwo, who stubbornly resists change in his village. There are no specific points of evidence brought up about Okonkwo or his village (other than he's stubborn); the author merely insists that "as time passed, changes began to form" in this village. These changes were apparently caused by "cultural persuasions", though no examples are given. The author attempts to relate back to the question in saying "Achebe's use of cultural changes and development makes the work apprehendable to realize that things do change and never stay the same", but the fact that no examples of cultural persuasions were presented in the essay make this statement irrelevant. Not only this, the author twists "apprehend" into a different form that makes no sense in the context of the sentence. Vague, incorrect diction and simplistic writing such as this appears all throughout the essay, as in "The village of the story during the time period has its difference and consists of contrasting views, opinions and characteristics about life", which make the piece as a whole difficult to read. Due to these errors, I would have to give this essayist a 3 for the work.
Drew,
ReplyDeleteYour responses to each of the student written essays are impressive! I can tell that you took the time to actually read each essay and analyze it. Your analysis of each is filled with lots of evidence from the actual essays which is one of the most important things, so nice job! I also really liked how professional and fair you were while "grading" these essays. I think we all now know how hard writing these essays can be and I can tell you kept that in mind while commenting on them. Do you think you have improved on your essay writing so far? I think I have a little but I still have far to go until I am ready to writing an impressive one with a time limit.
Drew,
ReplyDeleteWhile I know we did not call each other or something, I do think it’s interesting that we picked the same essay prompt; but like you said “that just means I've got a good benchmark for comparison”. Your analysis of each essay was good and I agree with pretty much everything you said. With response N, I agree that there was quite a bit of summary, but unlike you I don’t think I would have knocked the student down a point as it was all relevant and tied back to the question well. I thought your scores for responses J and UU were generous. You say there is a discernible skeleton of what the essayist is saying in response J, but I struggled to find it. I’m not even sure the essayist knows what they are saying or want to say. They started off with a good question but they rarely, if ever, returned to it! Likewise I feel that the essayist for UU had no real idea of what they were talking about; to me they seemed to be talking in circles and getting nowhere. Though I disagree a bit, you did a really good job analyzing these.
Drew,
ReplyDeleteIt's so convenient that you and Caitlin wrote about the same set of essays. I appreciate your telepathic relationship with regard to your choice of open prompts.
Like Caitlin said, I think you were a little too generous with your grading of the writing. Though I have a bad habit of expecting excellence out of these poor high school students that are just as unqualified as we are, I think that all of these essays could use some serious revision. Personally, I would give the first one anything between 5-7. Though the structure and evidence in the piece were much better in this compared to the other two, which would receive a much lower score, especially the last one; it hardly deserves a score.
As far as grading goes, though, you had plenty of textual evidence to support your claims, something that I think many of us tend to be lacking in our posts. You’re also very articulate in your writing in general, just as you are in real life. I appreciate that.