Sunday, January 12, 2014

Response to Prompt #1

Prompt: 2004 Form A - "Critic Roland Barthes has said 'Literature is the question minus the answer.' Choose a novel, or play, and considering Barthes' observation, write an essay in which you analyses a central question the work raises and the extent to which it offers answers. Explain how the author's treatment of this question affects your understanding of the work as a whole. Avoid mere plot summary."

As humans advanced into the modern age during the industrial revolution, optimists and dreamers began conjuring up images of success that have stuck with us to this day. These images revolve around hard work, dedication, and coming from the bottom and making it big: the prototypical American dream. In Arthur Miller's Death of a Salesman, the question of "what is the answer to becoming successful" is posed, often by Willie Loman, the play's main character, a question he has been searching for the answer to all his life.

The character of Willie Loman is one who has been consistently deluded by the ideals of "rags-to-riches" stories that have followed him throughout his life, though Willie has never been able to achive this kind of success. Willie's deceased brother Ben was a successful diamond miner who immigrated to Africa when he was 18 and made his fortune by age 21, at least according to Willie's memory. Before leaving, Ben had asked him to go with him (initially to Alaska to find their gold-mining father), but Willie decided not to. Willie had met an old salesman, one who had obtained success at his old age and was known by clients far and wide; he did not even have to leave his home to make a sale. Spurred by these successful images, Willie began searching for the kind of success Ben had through the masque of the old salesman. But, this kind of success was never achieved, and Willie eventually convinced himself that even though he was just another hard-working, penny-ante salesman, he was well-known, well-liked and successful. In the back of his mind, though, he knew that he was not like Ben and the old salesman. This repressed knowledge drives Willie's search for "the answer" to success, often asking the memory of Ben what it is; Ben never gives a straight answer, and neither do any of the other characters that he asks.

The lack of a clear answer to this question drives the themes and meanings found in this play. We discover through memories that Willie loves carpentry. He tells tales of when he built both the roof and the front porch to his house, and these parts of memories are often when we see him the happiest. Willie's son, Biff, also has been warped by the "rags-to-riches" perception of success. Biff was lauded as a child for his athletic ability, but was disillusioned when he discovered an affair his father was having. Since then, Biff has wandered from job to job, city to city, looking for work and himself, while his father desires that he become a salesman as well. Biff's true desires lie in manual labor and outdoor farm work, though he denies these feelings because of his father's influence. In his search for success, Biff practices self-sabotage whenever things are going well on a farm and returns to New York to get a "real" job, one he does not want. The characters of Biff and Willie are both looking for the same thing, success, but their perceptions of success have been warped by the influence of others, and by the society that endorses these ideas. They go through life asking, out-loud and tacitly, "what's the answer?", when it lies in front of them the entire time. Miller does not provide an explicit answer, and, in a sense, that is the answer, that there isn't one. A person must discover his own answer and follow his own desires to become "successful", not conform to a predisposed notion of success. The failure to discover this by Willie eventually leads to his suicide, though Biff vows to follow through on his dreams and become what he may. The course of action Willie took lead to incredibly harmful consequences, mainly the emotionally damaged state that every one of his family members is in. This is the warning that Miller gives us, that the denial of true desires will lead to drastic, sometimes irreversible consequences.

As a modernist, questions about success and the validity of the American dream were hot on the minds of writers like Miller during the forties and fifties, and Death of a Salesman is a prime example of these questions. Miller does not go about finding the answer to success, but throws out the notion of a single answer, showing us how destructive and corrosive the search can be. It is no wonder that Miller was seen as a danger to the United States during these years in writing; a challenge to the status quo this big rivals another work along this same path, The Crucible, which decried the anti-Communist trials of Joe McCarthy. But he was merely following his own warnings, doing what he desired most in writing these controversial plays instead of giving his ideals up for safety.

1 comment:

  1. Drew, my good man,
    You exercise some fine writing here. Your sentences are crisp, your words cut like glass. I feel, in some sense, violated by your skill as a wordsmith.
    However, I'm not sure you fully answer the question posed by the prompt. You provide many excellent examples of places in Salesman where the question is posed, but you don't offer concrete answers. Your post seems to sort of wander away from the prompt, a little, and then concludes with the statement that the answer is no answer. I'm no AP Grader, but I don't think you stuck close enough to the prompt to get a high score. Next time, you should reign yourself in a bit, and organize your ideas in a clearer fashion.

    ReplyDelete