For 2008 Question 3
3A: 8
In this essay on The Joy Luck Club, the student writes an articulate, specific, and clear response that ties in neatly with the themes of the book. She immediately introduces her foil in the first sentence, and provides many specific, relevant details as to how the foil functions from a contrasting standpoint. Her ties back to the meaning are distinct ("actions in the relationship between Huang and Lindo illuminated the meaning of
The Joy Luck Club"), and her explanatory examples are precise. However, she does delve into some unnecessary summarizing in the beginning, and her thesis is merely a restatement of the prompt, but her essay as a whole saves her from losing much credit for this.
3B: 5
This student, writing about The Color Purple, does a passable job of answering the prompt. She does indeed introduce the elements of a foil and provides a specific example, but only at the end. Throughout the essay it is unclear as to who the foil for Celie is, as the author writes as if Celie's father and another character, Shug, could both be Celie's foil. It is only in the concluding paragraph that the author makes clear who Celie's foil is (her father). This points to her use of unspecific examples and summarizing. Though, not all is lost, as she does have a point to make and ties it back to the meaning of the book, she just does so in a sub-par manner.
3C: 3
In this response to The Kite Runner, the student does write a satisfactory response. While her examples are relevant to the question, all are simplistic and unspecific, and only at the end does she even attempt to tie them in with the meaning of the book. Her synthesis of the meaning itself is also lacking, writing that "The meaning of The Kite Runner is loyalty and friendship", but she does not expand on this vague statement. Not only are her examples simplistic, so is her writing style, which mainly employs short, choppy sentences that don't lend themselves to any sort of flow ("Baba wasn't a truthful person", "Baba is a very loyal character", etc.). Despite this discussion being vague and unfocused, it sticks with the book, and at least makes an attempt to answer the prompt adequately.
Hello Drew,
ReplyDeleteThe blog peer review assignment says that each comment for each post has to be 150-250 words. Why is 150-250 always the magic number? I don't know. Anyways, I am trying to say that whatever I say may not fill the requirements, but is the only thing I can think of saying (tongue-twister): please expand. Although you do a fine job analyzing the technical pros and cons of each response, I feel that you aren't saying why the student received the score that was received. The last excerpt was done well, but the first two I feel need more explanation and input from your thoughts and more examples. A lot of what you say can be classified as claims, and I feel that you could try to tie the prompt in. Also, I feel like you could expand on how the writer uses words and such to support his/her argument.
Not that I could do better. I can't.
Drew,
ReplyDeleteAfter reading your response to these students, I'm questioning if I did this assignment wrong, or perhaps you did. Don't get me wrong your in depth analysis was spot on, however, it was to my understanding that we were supposed to analyze 3 different students response to the same text. Feel free to correct me if I'm wrong, because I very well may be. Aside from that, I agree mostly with your scoring. One thing I would have liked to see more of us is some examples pulled directly from the students essays. Despite this, I think your ideas were perfect and justified your scoring well. I particularly applaud your analysis on the third response. I can see why you gave her the score you did. From your evidence, I can see the short sentences, and simplistic writing style that you referred too. Overall, I love your sophisticated writing style, and agree with your reasoning as to why you gave the students the scores you did. Good job!
Drew,
ReplyDeleteI wish you would have analyzed these responses further through more direct examples. Sometimes you summarize the students' responses rather than going into detail about the level of their insight or support. In the first response, you make the claim that the author "provides many specific, relevant details as to how the foil functions from a contrasting standpoint", but you don't elaborate further. You could definitely go into more depth into how specifically the responses incorporated DIDLS to answer the magical AP Lit question: "how does the author use techniques to create effects or meanings?" I think you focused too much on the structure and composition of the student responses and less on their specific points. Especially in the 2nd analysis, you only touch on compositional flaws rather than on the student's actual supporting points. Overall, less general statements and more in-depth analysis!