Sunday, September 15, 2013

Close Reading #1

"Rock Lyrics Are Poetry (Maybe)" http://robertchristgau.com/xg/music/lyrics-che.php

Robert Christgau is known as the "Dean of American Rock Critics" for good reason. His short, biting, and often sardonic reviews have been the basis for a good deal of American music criticism, as well as a good deal of controversy. Praise does not flow freely from Christgau; and many artists have been torn apart by his acidic tongue. His writing style is very distinctive, and in the longer piece "Rock Lyrics Are Poetry (Maybe)" his use of diction, imagery and syntax all help to create his signature forceful, sardonic approach to writing.

In essence, Christgau makes the claim that rock lyricism, however poetic-sounding, rarely reaches the literary level of actual poetry, and that a simpler approach does the job more effectively. His use of diction to reach this point can be summed up quite neatly as "extreme." Christgau loves to speak in terms of absolutes, and he propels their supposed absolution along with hard-hitting, concrete words that are heavy with meaning. When describing the work of Paul Simon in the seventh paragraph, he ends the section with "Each song is perfect. And says nothing." Christgau is essentially throwing any and all possible interpretations of Simon's work out the window with those two sentences, with the word "nothing" being the driver behind the force. "Nothing", being the absence of all things, is so freakishly intense for Christgau not to mean it ironically. Of course he isn't saying that every single song Paul Simon ever wrote is entirely devoid of meaning; that would be absurd. Using extreme diction ironically helps sharpen the idea that there is very little poetic meaning in Simon's work, no matter how poetic Simon may sound. Other extreme words such as "masterwork" and "idiot(ic)" appear in sarcastic descriptions of songs and lyrics, words which stab and jab at the artist and reader alike. Conversely, when he writes of something he agrees with or enjoys, Christgau dispenses of extreme language and goes for a softer, less sarcastic approach, such as calling John Phillips (a member of The Mamas and the Papas) a "good lyricist" who has a "tender respect" for pop music. But, this kind of diction does not appear often in this piece.

Like his diction, Christgau's imagery is quite biting. In the fourth paragraph, writing about Bob Dylan,
he describes Dylan's rhymes as "clackety-clack" and his images as "scattergun." These two words conjure up very telling images relating directly to the folksinger myth that Dylan embodied so well. Firstly, "clackety-clack" is an onomatopoeia, and what better to go clackety-clack than a railroad grade buckling under the weight of a train? The idea of movement via trains is very prominent in American folk song; and Dylan himself fantasized about hoboing his way across America in a box car like his hero Woody Guthrie. When Christgau brings up that image to criticize Dylan's work, it undermines Dylan's folksiness in a big way, as if he's saying that his folksy rhymes fail to be so. "Scattergun" also invokes images from American folk-song, but this time it comes from the cowboy song tradition of guns, guts and women. However, this image doesn't function as well as the first, as Dylan sang far fewer cowboy songs than train songs, but the relationship is still there. Christgau brings up other images in the piece, but these two are the most direct.
 
Christgau uses syntax in this piece to great advantage, mainly to hammer home some of the ironic absolutes found all over the work. Most of the paragraphs in this piece begin with a blunt, declarative sentence: "The songwriter who seems to sound most like a poet is Bob Dylan" or "Not much is better than the self-indulgence of the Doors' Jim Morrison." Not only does this set the paragraph up, it prepares the reader for the even shorter and blunter sentences to come where the real points are driven home. At the end of the second paragraph, Christgau ends his thoughts with "Poems are read or said. Songs are sung." No wiggle room there, apparently; but again, irony is king. While he is saying that poetry and songwriting are two distinct art forms, he is not saying that only poems should be read and songs should be sung. In contrast, Christgau sometimes employs syntax that is deliberately hackneyed as a setup to a short declarative phrase. A wonderful example appears in the twelfth paragraph: "'San Francisco--Flowers In Your Hair', catering to every prurient longing implicit in teenage America's flirtation with the hippies without ever even mentioning the secret word, is a stunning piece of schlock." Instead of continuing in the inflated vein that comprises the first part of the sentence, he cuts it off with a blunt colloquial phrase, one anyone could understand. This simple, to-the-point syntax relates directly to the point Christgau is trying to make about rock lyrics: if they were simpler, then maybe they'd be poetry.

Rock 'n' roll, for all its "yeah yeah yeahs", sometimes seems to run deeper than just those on-the-surface sentiments, and the Dean of American rock critics is always present to dive into those depths. Sometimes he comes up with golden praise, sometimes with the piranha-like criticism found here, where extreme diction, sarcastic imagery and punctual syntax all work against the poor artists under attack here. Christgau knows how to direct his attacks with precision, so even if one doesn't like his opinions, he or she could at least appreciate Christgau's usage of these techniques.

Christgau, Robert. "Rock Lyrics Are Poetry (Maybe)." Web. 15 September 2013.

5 comments:

  1. Drew,
    Firstly, I'd like to praise you for your opening paragraph. It was very helpful that you gave some background info on the critic and what his critiques usually consist. Further down, you dove into the meaning or rather lack thereof of the word "nothing." I found this perplexing and think you did a great job of describing it's function to the passage as a whole. You had strong evidence throughout your entire post. As I said to Andrew, one thing that could have perfected your piece (hard to find a critique i must say) would have been a concluding paragraph. This would function as a tie to the knot. In this paragraph it would have been helpful if you outlined not only each individual element, but also how each element worked together as a whole to create a sardonic effect. Overall, I your piece was very thought provoking. I found this particular post of mine was a struggle, and reading yours gave me some good ideas for future posts.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Hello Drew,
    Very well done. Very well done indeed. I could tell that you were very into this article not only because of the length of your post, but also the great detail that you go into the article. The language you used proved you were passionate about this article's subject, which I really appreciated. You list each of the different aspects that you looked at (imagery, detail, and syntax) and then practically dissect the article bit by bit. I was especially impressed with how you came up with examples and not only described them, but also dove into how each contributes and builds upon the article's message and meaning as a whole. I, like Alex, had difficulty on this post, as I didn't really see how the different literary techniques resulted in anything. This is a stellar model for future posts for not just yourself, but also to all of us.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Drew,
    I like your organization of this blog post, first stating the meaning, then honing in on the details AND examples. Also, excellent transitions throughout your post: i.e. "conversely, ...", "firstly...", etc. Your detail in this blog post is astounding - from your examples, I can gather easily the techniques used by Christgeau to prove his point. But I'm impressed with not only the extent of details, but also the quality of the details. For example, the "clackety-clack" observation was incredibly insightful! Thank you for this quintessential example of a close reading response.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Excellent work, Drew. This still has a 9/15 post date--did you revise? Your peer reviewers say it lacks a conclusion, but I see one here that wraps up your thinking clearly--so I'm a bit...???

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I initially did not have a conclusion, and I did write the one currently here in the revision period. Blogger must've not changed the date for some reason, and I'm sure I added it after the first time I posted this.

      Delete