Saturday, March 15, 2014

Response to Course Material #7

Many, many events of certain various natures have transpired in the space of time since last there was assigned a post of this type; and if that wasn't vague or hackneyed enough for you, then I might as well stop trying. Let's see, we finished Rosencrantz and Guildenstern are Dead, began Ceremony, started examining critical lenses, and have had such a fun time doing so. The end of discussion to R&G was a bittersweet one indeed; I greatly enjoyed the play and loved discussing it and hearing the multitude of opinions that were revealed. At the tail end of our discussions the Postmodernist reading of the play was thrown into the blender, and for our class I think it made us accept not writing a classwide theme statement a little easier. The very fact that we did that is kind of surprising, as we'd all become so accustomed to that practice, but the essay really showed my class that differing interpretations were all right and even necessary. Synthesizing the play into one concise theme statement to be agreed upon by all would take away the essential ambiguity of the work, the essayists seemed to be saying, and I think some of us in second hour agreed with this. Sometimes I wrestle with this notion, though, of a work being almost inherently meaningless so an audience can find their own meanings. R&G is far more concrete in meaning than other Postmodern works, but other ones, such as certain Bob Dylan songs, are downright meaningless, and inherently so. Take, for instance, the songs "Stuck Inside of Mobile With the Memphis Blues Again" and "Sad-Eyed Lady of the Lowlands", two songs off of Dylan's 1966 album Blonde on Blonde. Both of these songs rely almost exclusively on bizarre imagery, "poetic" comparisons, and sheer length (go check 'em out; give 'em a listen or read the lyrics, which can be found on this site, dylanchords, or don't do anything, I don't control you). I've been listening to Bob Dylan for most of my life, and have listened to both of these songs a fair number of times; I couldn't tell you anything about their meaning. Not one word. I'm more partial to "Stuck Inside of Mobile", but that's because I like the music more than "Sad-Eyed Lady." Did Dylan intend for these songs to contain clear meaning, or was he, in the style of Jackson Pollack, simply slinging words at a blank page and hoping that someone might be able to figure their meaning out? For if a piece can be interpreted in any manner possible, then isn't it just plain meaningless; and that begs the question, what's the point? Don't get me wrong, I love Bob Dylan's music to an almost inhuman extent, but sometimes when I sit there listening I think to myself "What the hell? What's he getting at?" Those are my main qualms with modern and post-modern art that we deal with on a daily basis in AP Lit.

To change gears, Ceremony has now begun. So far, am I enjoying it; it is quite unlike most of the Native American literature that I've been exposed to over the years. Yeah, I took American lit; I saw Smoke Signals, and frankly, I detested it, but Silko is not Alexie, and Ceremony is certainly not Smoke Signals. After reading Silko's essays on her own cultural experience, Ceremony has become quite an intense work to read, almost an exhausting one. The huge range of emotions expressed, from cathartic joy to the most extreme lows of fear and anxiety take their toll on the reader, not to mention the jumping and skipping between narrative voices and time periods; it's hard to comprehend all at once. If I hadn't read Silko's essays, the narrative flow would have made no sense, but after reading that in Pueblo culture a story cannot be explained just by itself; a virtual history must be included for it to make any sense. As of writing this, I'm about two-thirds into the book, and I cannot yet see a resolution to Tayo's internal grief. I'm looking forward to discussing this work; I've heard many terrible things about it from previous AP students, and so far they've all been untrue for me, but I'm sure there's somebody out there this year that doesn't like this book. As I've been reading, one story so similar to Tayo's keeps coming back, the story of Ira Hayes, who is immortalized in the song written by Peter LaFarge about his life ("The Ballad of Ira Hayes"; here's a good version Townes Van Zandt; Ira Hayes). Ira Hayes was a member of the Arizona Pima tribe and was one of the flag-raisers in the famous photograph taken atop Iwo Jima. He was a decorated soldier, a war hero, and even appeared in a film with John Wayne, but he fell into a pattern of alcoholism and depression close to the one Silko explores in her novel. Hayes was never comfortable with his fame, and died of exposure after a night of drinking ten years after his famous contribution to World War II. Now, I am not Hayes, I cannot see into his mind, wherever it may be, but I feel that he experienced much of the same detachment and alienation that Tayo did after the war ended. Perhaps Silko had the story of Hayes in the back of her mind when she wrote this book, along with all of her own stories and experiences, but there is certainly a clear connection.

Critical lenses was, strangely enough, something I didn't expect to encounter in AP Lit. Now, that is a quite a silly thought, considering critical lenses are about the biggest thing to consider when interpreting any work of literature, but I'm just a silly teenager who doesn't think about things. The powerpoint and lecture that we saw were both quite revealing, for I knew a vague outline of varying critical lenses from my American Lit days, though these two materials explained them in greater detail and showed some of the history behind them. Of course we all loved the dancing urinal. There's no question that we didn't, but I'm finding the current discussions on all the works we've read this year when put under those lenses a bit more stimulating (though we should all get black bodysuits and carve urinal headgear and wear it to the AP test). Unfortunately, I haven't been to AP Lit very much over the past few days of discussions, so I've missed much of what was said.

Lastly, let's talk about AP essays. Honestly, I don't know what I'm going to do any more. I spent over two hours going over the most recent closed prompt revision, pretty much tearing it down to the roots and reconstructing something more coherent. The test allows for forty minutes. Oh poop. Strangely enough, I'm not that frightened about the thing, despite only being two months away. Maybe I should become frightened. It might make cause me to write better. Or seize up. One of the two. Fifty-fifty chance, and we all know what happens when people deal with the same side of two coins...

3 comments:

  1. Is it unethical to give a student extra credit just because he links to a TVZ song in a blog post?

    ReplyDelete
  2. Drew,
    First, lol at Holmes' comment. This is possibly the longest response to course material I've ever encountered, which is certainly not a bad thing. You hit every major point necessary, so I don't think there's anything you should change.
    As you mentioned in your response to my blog, we agree on the fact that R&G simply cannot be broken down into one all-encompassing theme statement. I feel like it would be more conducive to in-depth analysis to create three and write a short analysis on all of them. That way we could ensure that we hit a variety of important central themes rather than simply one.
    Also, I'm not sure if you meant to reference to a lyric from Samson and Delilah by the Grateful Dead in your comment but you did, and I love you for it.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I very much intended to reference that lyric. ;-)

      Delete