Sunday, February 9, 2014

In Response to an Open Prompt

2003: According to critic Northrop Frye, “Tragic heroes are so much the highest points in their human landscape that they seem the inevitable conductors of the power about them, great trees more likely to be struck by lightning than a clump of grass. Conductors may of course be instruments as well as victims of the divisive lightning.” Select a novel or play in which a tragic figure functions as an instrument of the suffering of others. Then write an essay in which you explain how the suffering brought upon others by that figure contributes to the tragic vision of the work as a whole. 


When we first meet the character of Hamlet, it is uncertain as to what he will do about the Claudius-Gertrude debacle that has consumed his life and taken him from his collegiate studies. But once he receives the ghost’s command to exact revenge on a treacherous brother, Hamlet’s actions become unfocused and wild, the opposite of what one would expect to happen. In this wildness, he cuts down many before him, though he never reaches the king himself until the end. Firstly, he begins with Ophelia, who he debases with harsh speech and claims that she is a whore after his “To be, or not to be” soliloquy. This begins Ophelia’s downward spiral, continued further by the murder of her father, Polonius. Eventually, Ophelia, who may also be pregnant with Hamlet’s child, can take no more of the strife she has to deal with and commits suicide, while remaining mainly innocent in regards to the affairs of Elsinore. Polonius, too, is cut down by Hamlet, though his involvement with Claudius does link him directly to the continued corruption and treachery in Denmark. Polonius is frequently ridiculed by Hamlet in passing, and Hamlet demonstrates no sorrow in killing Polonius accidentally. Rosencrantz and Guildenstern are treated not as friends but as spies; Hamlet makes no attempt to try and win them over to his side, instead sending them to their deaths cold-heartedly. Hamlet treats his mother with less than kindness and inadvertently leads to her death at the end of the play, when Claudius’s plot backfires on him. And at the end of the play, when all the main players are dead, Hamlet gives the gutted kingdom of Denmark over to Norway, who was merely passing through, handing the control of its citizens over a foreigner that once warred against them. Hamlet never succeeds in efficiently killing his target, Claudius, who dies only out of the convenience of the situation at the play’s end.


As the play unfolds, we see that Hamlet’s inability to act quickly and efficiently stems from an identity crisis. Hamlet is supposed to be nothing more than a carbon-copy of his father, a violent, uncompromising leader that would go into battle to defend his kingdom at any cost. We see that Hamlet thinks nothing like this: he is contemplative, inquisitive, and in a sense, very new-age, as he has absorbed many Protestant ideals from his studies in Wittenberg. He is a Renaissance man grappling with the ideas of a past that he rejects, a past that is ever-present and ever-influential in his life. This is this reason that Hamlet destroys so much in the course of this play; he cannot reconcile himself with his surroundings. And, in turn, this compromises all of Hamlet’s moral judgment, leading him to hurt and kill those around him, whether he wants to or not. This leaves us readers with Shakespeare’s warning that a confused identity results in the compromise of morality, and that this may lead to catastrophic results, especially for such a large character as Hamlet.

We learn much from Shakespeare’s works today; his command of the English language and the ideas that accompany them have proved themselves timeless again and again. It is messages such as the ones accompanying Hamlet that keep people coming back to them, for we all have experienced identity crises at one point or another, and have felt their effects on our minds and bodies. Hamlet never intended to cause so much pain when he received the ghost’s order; he was paralyzed by his surroundings and could not escape. His stature was so large that in his fall from grace, he took a seemingly impossible number of people with him.

5 comments:

  1. Hi Drew!

    Nice job on this post! I think you did a really good job of proving how Hamlet brings down those around him. However, it seems like there are a few elements missing. Where's your opening paragraph? That's kind of important.

    I also think you could have transitioned between your body paragraphs more smoothly. Having a thesis paragraph would help with this, I think, because it gives you a good outline to work the rest of your essay around. Right now, it seems like you jump pretty abruptly between your proof paragraph and your meaning paragraph. While you bring in Hamlet's position as an "instrument of suffering" later on in the paragraph, I think it would be good to address that in the opening sentence of that paragraph as well, so the two don't seem so disjointed.

    I think you did a really good job answering this prompt. Nice work!

    ReplyDelete
  2. Hi Drew,

    Nice essay! It has become quite evident to me that you understand Hamlet very, very well. Your examples are great. But, I do think the format of the essay could be a bit better. Generally we would start with an introduction that answers the prompt. Then it can be followed by 2 - 3 body paragraphs, and then the conclusion. I also noticed the use of first person ("we") but AP essays should only use third person. I feel that although your examples here are superb, they could be arranged within the essay to create a better flow. I think using more transition words will help. Also, for me personally, I feel that "cutting down" someone could have various meanings, and AP readers only have a few minutes to read your essay and give a score. I guess in this essay, to "cut down" someone is quite literal and metaphorical so it worked in this case, but just be careful for other essays to be as clear as possible.

    Overall, very nice job answering the prompt! I know Holmes just taught us how to write a correct AP Lit essay a few days ago, and this was prior to all that information, so yes I too have many of the same errors and a mountain of other errors too. I really enjoyed reading this essay, it's evident you know Hamlet very well and your evidence is great. Nice job!

    ReplyDelete
  3. Oh lawdy, it seems that Blogger ate my first paragraph, or, I forgot to copy and paste it out of the Word document I had open into my post. Well, what's done is done. I did write an intro paragraph, though looking back it was pretty bad so I'm kind of glad no one read it, but it exists, somewhere in the nebulous world of my computers hard-drive. Reading this thing now, I understand how nonsensical it must've been. Good thing I won't be copying and pasting in the actual AP exam.

    ReplyDelete
  4. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Nice work! Your solid understanding of the prompt is clearly evident in your first body paragraph. Initially, I was a little curious as to why your essay started so abruptly without any real introduction, but I totally sympathize with your computer troubles. Happens to me all the time. Maybe you should still post your intro, though, so that Ms. Holmes can at least see that you have one. Aside from that, you've got some great stuff going on here. I like the way you organized your paragraphs to answer the goal first and then tackle the meaning on its own. That gives the piece a logical progression that helps me follow along as a reader. It seems like your conclusion could benefit from a little more focus. As a stand alone paragraph, it's really quite eloquent, but I feel like you might want to hone back into that thesis statement more clearly at the end to ensure that it gets the emphasis it deserves. Other than the missing intro, this is a admirable essay. Good stuff, Drew.

    ReplyDelete