Sunday, January 19, 2014

Response to Course Material #5 (And #4)

Well, I am officially a lazy arse. Because of my total apathy towards all things in existence and the angsty, existential questions that are constantly swirling around in my head, I did not do the last post of this type, due quite a while ago. So, in a lame effort to make up for that, I'm going to include, in brief, my thoughts on the many versions of Hamlet that we viewed before the break. That's more for my sake than anyone else's, though; I'll begin with our final discussions of the play.

After many wondrous days of delay, we finally got around to finalizing our views on Hamlet, and I can tell you, a early-three-week break does not do good things for a discussion on such a complicated play. Every time we began discussing, it took a little time for us to get into it, but we eventually got some good work done. Initially, our hour engaged the concept of the play's turning point and where it might be, along with working out the play's central question. Most all of us agreed that control was such an overarching construct in this play that it had to be included in the question, and our question ended up being "Will Hamlet relinquish control of himself?" In the end, he does, and this is where the debate of the play's turning point began: when exactly does Hamlet relinquish control? Two schools of thought emerged on the subject, one pointing towards the "Poor Yorick" scene, the other to the scene where Hamlet speaks with Horatio before the duel. I believe our class settled pretty evenly on the "Poor Yorick" scene, wherein Hamlet comes to terms that his father was not much of a father figure. This frees Hamlet from his filial obligation and allows him to give control to God, which happens in his conversation with Horatio. We then moved on to the theme statement, which I would usually equate to pulling one's teeth out with needle-nose pliers, but this time around, things went surprisingly smooth. There was little dissent towards the final product (the text of which I cannot remember), and it seems that all that's left is to write the post and wade through the extremely long list of motifs that we also compiled.

Now onto ancient history. Long before the fabled winter break of 2013-2014, our classes viewed many snippets of differing interpretations of Hamlet (among other things), and there was much rejoicing. What I found interesting about this viewing process was the extremes that directors and actors take when interpreting such a famous work. Take, for instance, Derek Jacobi's version of Hamlet. In my opinion, his performance as the titular character sometimes bordered on childishness. The way he thrashed about after his meeting with the ghost almost made me laugh. But then came Lawrence Olivier's reading of Hamlet, which lies in a completely different realm. Olivier kept the character sharp and thoughtful; his emotions rarely boiled over to the same point as Jacobi's. Overall, I thought Olivier displayed a more realistic range of emotion in respect to how I read the character of Hamlet, and I viewed him more as a calculated thinker than a mad hatter. Every interpretation that we explored during this time, including the African tribe's reading and the version given by prisoners, rose a question that has long troubled artists and thinkers: who should we trust? Whose word is the final word? Is there even a final word? And if there isn't, what does that mean for a work? This class has emphasized the idea that differing interpretations are the backbone of literary thought and criticism, and I understand this, but still, what's going on? There are many thousands of people who have taken their stab at interpreting Hamlet, though essays and films and stage productions, but this leaves us with a whirlwind of thoughts and ideas that can be extremely confusing to sort through. I'm still not sure how to work with the essay we read outlining the various theories and schools of thought behind Hamlet; that, in and of itself, was a confusing, messy blob of ideas. If one essay fails to effectively explain and work through Hamlet, then what of the other thousands trying to do the same thing? They so often contradict and refute each other, trying to gain a higher position on the hierarchical ladder of literary thought, and many are left by the wayside to rot. I've often wavered between objectivity and subjectivity in literature, and Hamlet only worked to confuse my thoughts more (not necessarily in a bad way, for it's always good to think). I doubt that I'll reach a resolution any time soon; and I'd like to hear any opinions anyone has on the matter.

Another point that was made during these past weeks was made by my father, who I was discussing these various films with. We were talking about Kenneth Branagh's version, which he had given five stars in his own film rating system (my father is an avid lover of film, and I often ridicule his picky, sometimes venomous rating system; he rarely gives ratings over one-half star). I had my own issues with Branagh's version, namely the extroverted, grandiose nature of the whole thing, and the silly ending with the big fight scene and Fortinbras's masculine, powerful entrance. He refuted these points though, and said that he gave the film five stars because every single line is included, and that despite the directorial and acting flaws that may be present, the words of Shakespeare reign supreme overall. One can still become familiar with some of the greatest literature ever written in the English language, despite the medium of film and its flaws. This idea can be applied to the story we listened to about Hamlet being performed by prisoners. The obvious flaw there is that those prisoners were not professional, trained actors; they were just people, yet they still managed to convey the messages of Shakespeare. They connected immensely with the characters and words that were written hundreds of years ago, putting their own emotions into text that has been read before the highest of the high. My father convinced me to let off a bit on Branagh's version, flawed as it may be, because I still have one of the greatest works of all time to listen to while watching Robin Williams appear quite arbitrarily and Hamlet swing down from a giant chandelier. It may not have redeemed the film as a whole for me, but it made me appreciate the words of Shakespeare all the more.

1 comment:

  1. Drewseph McKilpela,
    I wholly appreciate your endeavor to make up for you skipped post. It represents strength and bravery, courage unbeknownst to students such as myself.
    Your recollection of our most recent course materials seemed a little bit skimpy. You merely regurgitate what we did in class, without offering any emotional insight, questions, or extra-curricular connections.
    The "make-up" portion of your post goes much more in depth. Your recollection of the filmed versions of Hamlet is impressively detailed. You also pose interesting questions about the subject of literature, and take us through your thoughts on the matter. It's delightful. You should do more of that, but with more connections to other films/books/plays.
    And challenge your father. Five is a big number.

    ReplyDelete